Where would you rank these guys all time?

[OumaFan]

I was a fan and I don't know if I'd have stayed up till 4, if you live in the US they come on at like 10, something to think about

who would you have rated the highest out of those listed?

Why have you made a serious thread? This is quite worrying.. am i meant to say Pac is no.1

Roy is the best of that lot.

Roy beat Hopkins, Toney and way past his best had some success (decked him) against Calzaghe.

Lopez has no star names.

Pac and Marquez are basically the same. Mosley is a hot-&-cold merchant.

I used to make serious threads all the time when I was a boxing fan

Not like I'm really gonna argue against Roy being rated the highest but I do think you can't just write off the last six or so fights

anyways

Morales

Barrera

ODLH

LOL, just kidding ODLH isn't a top 100 fighter

[HattonTheHammer]

i really hope marquez doesnt do a morales and fight on 1-2 fights longer than he should do (not that he should retire yet)

Of the current batch only pac, marquez, mosley can be considered potential hall of famers

[JazMerkin]

i really hope marquez doesnt do a morales and fight on 1-2 fights longer than he should do (not that he should retire yet)

Of the current batch only pac, marquez, mosley can be considered potential hall of famers

Bernard Hopkins

[OumaFan]

Floyd obviously is a lock

Some of his fans will never admit but he did deserve some of the shit he got there for a while but his resume is there, even if he doesn't come back he's clearly top 100 no doubt, top 50 I would say.

[holmcall]

Ricardo Lopez--Very High

Joe Calzaghe-- Very high

Bernard Hopkins--very high

Manny Pacquaio - tbd

Juan Manuel Marquez -tbt

James Toney. high but he is ruining his legacy by staying on too long

Sugar Shane Mosley- tbd

Roy Jones-very high

[JazMerkin]

Ricardo Lopez - 20-30

Joe Calzaghe - 70-80

Bernard Hopkins - 10-20

Manny Pacquaio - 70-80

Juan Manuel Marquez - 80-90

James Toney - 70-80

Sugar Shane Mosley- 60-70

Roy Jones - 10-25

Floyd Mayweather - 10-20

Some of those can change & get higher such as Pac & JMM & even Floyd & JC if they were to come back. The RJJ one I found the hardest as in his prime, I would have had him easily up in the top 10, however, the last few years have really damaged. I honestly don't think I could make a decent assessment until at least 5 years after all these guys are retired