Where would you rank these guys all time?

**OumaFan** · 03-12-2009 02:36 PM

Floyd obviously is a lock

Some of his fans will never admit but he did deserve some of the shit he got there for a while but his resume is there, even if he doesn't come back he's clearly top 100 no doubt, top 50 I would say.

**holmcall** · 03-12-2009 02:39 PM

Ricardo Lopez--Very High

Joe Calzaghe-- Very high

Bernard Hopkins--very high

Manny Pacquaio - tbd

Juan Manuel Marquez -tbt

James Toney. high but he is ruining his legacy by staying on too long

Sugar Shane Mosley- tbd

Roy Jones-very high

**JazMerkin** · 03-12-2009 02:46 PM

Ricardo Lopez - 20-30

Joe Calzaghe - 70-80

Bernard Hopkins - 10-20

Manny Pacquaio - 70-80

Juan Manuel Marquez - 80-90

James Toney - 70-80

Sugar Shane Mosley- 60-70

Roy Jones - 10-25

Floyd Mayweather - 10-20

Some of those can change & get higher such as Pac & JMM & even Floyd & JC if they were to come back. The RJJ one I found the hardest as in his prime, I would have had him easily up in the top 10, however, the last few years have really damaged. I honestly don't think I could make a decent assessment until at least 5 years after all these guys are retired