are Oasis the biggest ever band to not make it in america??

[Gandalf]

I detest Miles's bitching.

Come on now. It was only a mild bitch here, Booze. I've done far worse bitching than this. Be Here Now should have been ruled a NC.

I'm afraid I must disagree. Be Here Now, while not on the same level as ...Morning Glory or Definitely Maybe was still a very good album. It was the last good Oasis album IMO, and I'm Canadian so I would know .

I think there are good tracks on it, but it is a meandering album. It's too long and too much filler. I really like "Stand by me", "Don't go away" and "fade-in-out". But that's it really. Tracks like "Magic Pie" and "The girl in the dirty shirt" are beyond awful IMO. The rockier tracks that Oasis are usually good at have fall short too. It's all over produced.

I don't think Oasis have made a good album since "Morning Glory". I will quit the bitching in case Booze goes off on one!