With Both Now "Retired," Who Had The Better Legacy, Oscar or Floyd

[BoomBoom]

Oscar is in Floyds list but Floyd is not in Oscars list? Speaks for itself really

Oscars legacy overshadows Floyds in my opinion, too many great names.

The list is of the fighters they have beaten. As Floyd beat Oscar he gets him on the list.

Genaro Hernandez should be on Floyd's list as well btw.

Good call. I kept to 15 but I could replace Augustus or Sosa with Genaro. I kept it to 15 wins a piece though.

[Spicoli]

I have to go with Oscar....god I never thought I'd say that .Going on longevity,overall competition,facing adversity and division spans.He had some ups and downs,but was willing to go at the top for the entirity of career.Floyd Imo has the better skills clearly but might not have given himself the chance to realize his full potential & greatness.

BoomBoom,why are you hating on Troy Dorsey like that lol . Side note....Genaro DEFINATLY belongs on Floyds list,Imo.

[BoomBoom]

I have to go with Oscar....god I never thought I'd say that .Going on longevity,overall competition,facing adversity and division spans.He had some ups and downs,but was willing to go at the top for the entirity of career.Floyd Imo has the better skills clearly but might not have given himself the chance to realize his full potential & greatness.

BoomBoom,why are you hating on Troy Dorsey like that lol . Side note....Genaro DEFINATLY belongs on Floyds list,Imo.

I agree with everything you wrote. Floyds lack of risk taking deprived him of some big wins... I dont know how i forgot Dorsey, thats it Pernells getting bumped off....or maybe Camacho ...yeah ill go with him