With Both Now "Retired," Who Had The Better Legacy, Oscar or Floyd

[jon09]

Good thread but I might argue that Floyd is not 36 years old and not officially retired yet. Oscar has had more controversy in losses and in wins. Floyd has 1 controversy in Castillo which he beat him easier in a rematch and has not lost yet. Oscar has controversy with and no rematches with Pernell, Sturm, Quartey and I still think he took a dive in the Hopkins fight and had that marathon with Tito. I think a gold medal would have probably helped Pretty Boy Floyd alot more in the professionals like it did for Oscar. I think if Cotto would have beaten Margarito then I think Floyd would have fought him because it would have been a mega showdown that could have brought in alot of money. Oscar could have fought Margarito also but he chose to fight a smaller fighter in Pacman instead, which backfired on him in the worst way. I think as of now Floyd has a better legacy then Oscar.

[fan johnny]

I'll to go with Oscar on this one. Oscar got a statue!