IF Hatton beats Pacqauio does that mean he will be P4P #1?

[Britkid]

Far too much thought is put into creating no matter what happens a mythical title holder.

To a point it is ridiculous enough to rate for arguments sake, a thousand men who consider themselves Junior Welterweights.

To rate every single active professional fighter from the 4' 10" 105lber to the 7' 1" 350lber in one pound for pound division is .......


Fun, providing you do not put too much emphasis and indeed conditions on what is just an opinion.

[fan johnny]

If Hatton were to beat both Pacquiao and Mosley with Mayweather Jr out of the picture, I'd say he'd probably take over the #1 slot. If Mayweather is back into the consideration it throws the thing out of wack!

[Galaxy]

If Hatton were to beat both Pacquiao and Mosley with Mayweather Jr out of the picture, I'd say he'd probably take over the #1 slot. If Mayweather is back into the consideration it throws the thing out of wack!

If he beat both Pacquiao & Mosley it would be difficult not to rate Hatton 1st!

[CutMeMick]

If Hatton beats Pac he becomes #2.

1. JMM
2. Hatton
3.Pac


If Pac beats Hatton then Pac becomes #1.

1. Pac
2. JMM


Of course this is just MY opinion. I currently have JMM as #1

[Gandalf]

It's not just Hatton that's been saying it. I saw his Dad and DLH saying the same bloody thing in interviews. Well, DLH controls the world these days so perhaps he will be P4P no. 1.

As much as I like Hatton I would put him at number 5 if he wins. A follow up win over Marquez would take him to the top IMO. Two huge names in a row, you wouldn't be able to argue with that.

But beating Pac alone, who has been smoke and mirrors above 130, is not enough as far as I'm concerned.

[Taeth]

Smoke and mirrors, honestly can a guy get no credit for destroying David Diaz and Oscar? Sure other people have beaten them before, but nobody came even close to doing to them what Pacquiao did. It was Oscar who was getting beat down in his last 3 fights but a guy who had a beat the crap out of Mayorga(way more impressively than Mosley), was competitive against Mayweather(except in the scoring sense if you have eyes), and won nearly every round against Forbes, and landed a lot considering how skilled defensively Forbes is, and its understandable he wasn't able to take the granite Forbes out who doesn't seem to get hurt(ala James Toney). Sure Oscar might have no quite been Oscar, but he didn't have the same type of terrible performances Casamayor against Cruz, or even the scare he had against Katsidis, he didn't lose to a journeyman like Nate Campbell either.

[ono]

I can cerainly see the argument for putting him at number 1.

He'll have beaten 3 top ten fighters in the last 4 years (tszyu #2/3, Castillo was at number 10 when the fight was made, maybe slipped down a few places when the fight took place and Pac is number 1)

The problem with saying he'd be outside the top 3 is the fact that you'd be hard pushed to put 3 fighters ahead of him. Pac would lose stock with a loss, JMM has lost and drawn with Pac, Hopkins has recently lost altho he looked exceptional beating Pavlik and Tarver, Mosely deserves props for his win against Margarito, but has lost to Cotto who lost to Margarito....argh! Vasquez has been inactive, so has Rafael Marquez.

At the minute i think a lot have him anywhere between 7-11 but that's with including 2 inactive fighters in Rafa Marquez and Israel Vasquez.

When i compiled my p4p ratings i ommited Marquez and Vasquez due to inactivity so in turn Hatton moved up a few places. A win over pacman would most likely move him up another 2/3 places.

I'd probably side with Mick who has him at #2 behind Marquez but again i wouldn't argue with anybody having Hatton at #1. Techincally he is probably a level below the guys around him but the fact is he has wins over Tszyu, Castillo, Malignaggi, Urango, Collazo and if he were to win he'd have one over Pacman.

[TitoFan]

If Hatton beats Pac he becomes #2.

1. JMM
2. Hatton
3.Pac


If Pac beats Hatton then Pac becomes #1.

1. Pac
2. JMM


Of course this is just MY opinion. I currently have JMM as #1

Hatton jumping to # 2 p4p for beating an undersized Pacquaio? Say it ain't so, Mick.

[Mark TKO]

Think I would put him about #4/5 if he beats Pac

But if he wins he has to go above Pac - so does that mean Pac drops to number 6 ?? No way will Pac drop that for.

It's a tough one - and where does PBF go when he announces his return (has that happened yet ? thought it was supposed to be yesterday he announced it but not seen owt on news)

Tomorrow morning I will give it some more thought

[Bomp]

Think I would put him about #4/5 if he beats Pac

But if he wins he has to go above Pac - so does that mean Pac drops to number 6 ?? No way will Pac drop that for.

It's a tough one - and where does PBF go when he announces his return (has that happened yet ? thought it was supposed to be yesterday he announced it but not seen owt on news)

Tomorrow morning I will give it some more thought

Does he? did Maxim suddenly become the GOAT p4per cos he beat SRR?

[ElTerribleMorales]

If Hatton beats Pac he becomes #2.

1. JMM
2. Hatton
3.Pac


If Pac beats Hatton then Pac becomes #1.

1. Pac
2. JMM


Of course this is just MY opinion. I currently have JMM as #1

Hatton jumping to # 2 p4p for beating an undersized Pacquaio? Say it ain't so, Mick.

Hatton was beaten by an "undersized" Mayweather, and should be given full credit if he beats Pacquiao, Trinidad was given credit for beating the undersized Mayorga, same will go for Berto if he beats Urango, and basically same crap happened when Khan beat Barrera, but yea i rank Hatton #5 if he beats Pacquiao, push Manny down to #3, JMM to #1, and B-Hop to #2

[TitoFan]

If Hatton beats Pac he becomes #2.

1. JMM
2. Hatton
3.Pac


If Pac beats Hatton then Pac becomes #1.

1. Pac
2. JMM


Of course this is just MY opinion. I currently have JMM as #1

Hatton jumping to # 2 p4p for beating an undersized Pacquaio? Say it ain't so, Mick.

Ok, this post left me totally confused.
Hatton was beaten by an "undersized" Mayweather, and should be given full credit if he beats Pacquiao (ok... he was beaten by the undersized Mayweather, so he should be given full credit for beating the undersized Pacquaio? WTF?), Trinidad was given credit for beating the undersized Mayorga,(Mayorga AND Trinidad both were out of their best weights when they fought at 160... example denied) same will go for Berto if he beats Urango, and basically same crap happened when Khan beat Barrera, but yea i rank Hatton #5 if he beats Pacquiao,(ok... at least you're not putting him at # 1, which is of course what I'm arguing against. I'm my personal opinion, I'd leave his exactly where he is now... 7 is it?) push Manny down to #3, JMM to #1, and B-Hop to #2

Uhhhh... see my comments above.