Beating the p4p no 3, doesnt make you top 5 p4p. Chavez was way better than any guy Hatton ever beat outside Tszyu. He's on the list. Tell me a guy Kostya wouldn't cane that Hatton fought, if the guy was as old as Phillips.

Try find ANYONE in the U.S. who thinks Hatton is better than Tszyu now, OR EVEN THEN. When the last time you saw Kostya Tszyu dismantled.. Never been done. Even when he lost, he still got some things done, and the man was 35!!

Gonzalez was MUCH better than a shot Castillo, as was Ruelas, as was Rodriguez, as was Pineda, as was almost everyone. Can you tell me in which way is a guy like Malinaggi anywher near a Sharmba Mitchel when he actually fought. Roger Mayweather was Tszyu first title defence, and he didnt win 1 round.

Like Phillips even compares to an old Julio Cesar Chavez. Kostya Tszyu was one year plus less age than Chavez. Who will Hatton be able to beat 4 months short of 36. Hatton was NEVER top 5 p4p. He had his LUCKY night in Manchester. Collozao, is that supposed to be your idea of a top boxer? I'll give you a top boxer, we can even go into the anateurs. Vernon Forrest.

Marquez won more rounds over 24 than Pacquiao. He would get killed against Tszyu at 140, he cannot do anything better. He cant pressure fight as well, they both can counter punch, though Tszyu is way more powerful, and has a much better right hand.

Hatton can't even do two rounds with Pacquiao, the same guy Marquez bettered over 24 in most peoples opinion. Tszyu was almost the same age as Julio Cesar Chavez. Tszyu was just plain OLD. Throw in a ref who cant give Kostya a break. We all saw what happens to Hatton in Vegas. A fair ref, Hatton gets KOed, again, by an old man.

Besides living off his victory over an old man, if you call beating a shot Castillo an accomplishment, what else has he ever doen.