Who Would Win If Evander Holyfield Fought Joe Frazier?

[Kirkland Laing]

Frazier wins either on points or late stoppage in a brutal fight. Holyfield was a great fighter but against opposition that wasn't in the same league as the greats of the 1970s that Frazier fought.

[Rocky Balboa]

I would say Joe Frazier would win. Like ICB said, he fought a seamingly unbeatable opponent in Muhammad Ali and won (in their first fight). Then again he was destroyed brutally by George Foreman so who knows

[Nameless]

I would say Joe Frazier would win. Like ICB said, he fought a seamingly unbeatable opponent in Muhammad Ali and won (in their first fight). Then again he was destroyed brutally by George Foreman so who knows

I see your argument, however, I would say this: 1) Big George was a monster in itself and I don't think that the real deal would have done much better against him and second, Perhaps that the Smoking Joe-Foreman fight was a combining of a bad day at the office for Joe and the destructive capacities of George combined together.

[El Kabong]

Hell there is no shame in getting whupped by Big George, Evander had a 40+ year old Foreman and Big George gave Holyfield all he could handle.