Julio Cesar Chavez vs Pernell Whitaker

[Taeth]

It definitely wasn't Chavez at his best, It would be like IMO if Pacquiao beat Marquez at welterweight decisively, I don't think it would mean much because his style has more success moving up, and he's been at higher weights longer. I think don't think the CHavez-Whitaker fight determined who was the better fighter p4p on the ATG list, though I think Whitaker is better and that he would have beaten Chavez at 135, it is all guess work on our part, but I can't see somebody slower than Whitaker beating him, he is too slick, too evasive, too busy, and too good.

[Master]

Yes you are all right, I forgot JCC went up to welter and he was never any good at that weight. Also Pernell was an ATG at lightweight. Still felt like the best fighters meeting p4p at that time.