1st one that was I think, serious entertainment. Keith Hackney againsed that Emanuelle yarborough (spelling) in UFC 3 I think was, unreal. He was like 600+pounds and got battered but Keith broke his hand and was out after that.
I think in UFC 4 he (Keith) was againsed the guy that ran around the ring after the Kimo Gracie fight in UFC 3 (and got shouted at by Big John the ref). He was thumping him in the bollocks!
It was great then, proper like!
I think the "white people need a fight sport" comment is very accurate and appeals to whites of lower earnings, education, and age. It has a white trash appeal that people eat up.
"If there's a better chin in the world than Pryor's, it has to be on Mount Rushmore." -Pat Putnam.
Same weight or Floyd pushing 100 pounds? I'm really not sure I'm even followed the meaning of your post. Are you comparing Sylvia to the 50 y.o. who has never boxed being beat in MMA by a boxer? Sorry; just missing your point I think.
1st; Tim Sylvia was a joke; the Valuev of MMA but worse. He got his ass kicked out of UFC; and only reason he won in UFC was because he had decent take down defense and weighed around 300 pounds, but still got owned by Couture who is 45 years old and weighed about 70 pounds less and actually outboxed him{which isn't saying much} Tim went to an obscure org. and got pitted against Mercer and Tim Sylvia thought he was a good boxer; a jab and 10ft. reach; lol he thinks that makes him a good boxerHe always fought standing up and when he got matched up against Mercer I knew that, unless Mercer was senile, he would knock Sylvia right out and couldn't have been happier when he did. Mercer wouldn't have lasted 2-3 minutes against a submisson specialist.
If Floyd is saying MMA guys aren't on his level boxing wise I wholeheartedly agree; I've already said that. If he's saying that just generally speaking they have no fighting skills at all and he's an all around superior fighter to all of them he's delusional. I would however give Floyd a better shot at transitioning to MMA than an MMA guy going to boxing; because some guys like to "box" in MMA and Floyd would eat them up unless his hand broke and he started sobbing. And very few have even journeyman boxing skills...black, white, yellow, red or anything else.
For me I love boxing 1st....it's more pure, that's the best way I can desribe it.
Last edited by LEGION; 07-22-2009 at 12:37 AM.
Sylvia is a joke yet he's a 2 time UFC heavyweight championwhat does that say about MMA? my point is, MMA is pretty much overall a weak sport, anybody can beat anybody and there is no real DOMINANT fighter in the sport, aside from maybe Emilianenko (spelling?!?), you said "Tell me Floyd would stand a chance against a guy who outweighs him by almost 100 pounds like Dan Severn outweighed Joyce" so i ask you, name a fighter 50 yrs old who has little to no experience in boxing that can beat Mayweather, just the same way that Mercer KO'd Sylvia brutally, and to the other bolded part of your post, same way Severn and no other MMA fighter would last 12 rounds or even 10 rounds against a world class boxer, they only fight for 15 minutes on a non-title fight for godsake and 25 minutes in a championship fight, guess all that fondeling and dry humping on the floor really tires them out
Yep sometimes it gets like that. If you think MMA is a weak sport than I can't change that point of view, nor was that my intention in this thread to change anyone's mind who doesn't like it. I get sick of watching 2 wrestlers sweating in between each other's legs too
As far as no dominant people in MMA that's not true. Fedor Emilianko, Joyce Gracie, GSP, Anderson Sylvia, Lyoto Machida , BJ Penn, Tito Ortiz, Couture, Matt Hughes, Chuck Lidell all were or are very dominant.
Yeah Sylvia got ktfo by an old boxer. Just like I already said numerous times, some guys in MMA think they can box and when they try to stand with a real boxer they will get owned. I said Floyd would transition better to MMA because some of them dudes might think they can box him, and if someone tried they'd get owned; just like Sylvia did. Hell most people on the MMA forums were picking Mercer to win.
And to answer your question: no sir; I don't know any 50 y.o. with no experience who could knock out Floyd in a ring; same weight class. I don't know anyone right now who is a pro fighter who will beat him, much less ko him.
How has Mercer little to no experience in boxing he was a former heavyweight world champ?
And if you mean as I think you mean that Mercer was entering into an MMA contest so you mean show you a 50 year MMA star with no experience in boxing that could beat Floyd in a boxing fight, then you need to know that the Silvia Mercer fight was not an MMA fight.
It was sanctioned as a boxing fight until the authorities wouldn't allow that so it then became an MMA bout officialy but Slyvia pledged to keep it just to boxing, with only punches, so it was an almost 50 year old former world champ knocking out a 35ish year old with little to no boxing experience, basically the opposite point of what you are arguing.
Also have you ever stopped to consider that the reason its harder to make the transition to world class in boxing is because in boxing every other form of combat is outlawed?
If a world class boxer goes into MMA he is still allowed to box, but if a world class ju jitsu or greco roman wrestler enters boxing all of his skills are effectively outlawed so of course it would be harder.
Brock Lesnar wouldn't make it to heavyweight champ in boxing because his core advantage in MMA, wrestling and that sheer overpowering physicality would be outlawed in boxing. He'd just have to stand up and punch and his lack of experience would see him getting owned.
Put him in a ring with either Klitschko where its anything goes however and my money is on Brock coming out on top. They would have to land one on him quick before he got to them else they are being pounded and brutalised on the ground.
Maybe they would do better than that I don't know, they are very big strong guys themselves after all, my point is though that its much easier to make the transition from boxing to MMA because you have already mastered one aspect of mixed martial arts, i.e use of the fists. For an MMA star however much of what they have learned is usueless to them in boxing because its not allowed.
Well Bilbo it was supposed to be just boxing but it wasn't, Sylvia threw a leg kick before, it just wasn't caught on the tape of the KO.
But I still don't get ElTerrible's point thoughMercer would be decimated by most good MMA heavyweights but if he gets off that one big punch early in a fight, like he did with Sylvia, he's got a chance because obviously punching is his strong point. But he gets annihalated 99 times out of 100 by Fedor, Lesnar, etc because he can only box.
Of course MMA guys aren't going to be as good in boxing as boxers though. They have to work on a ton of different stuff, not just boxing. The Floyd comparison is poor on a number of points, one obviously Floyd is at a much higher level in his sport than Tim Sylvia was, but also putting an MMA guy in boxing is taking away most of his strong points and making him just focus on one thing which may not be his strong suit, putting a boxing guy in MMA is disadvantageous to him but he's not being forced to throw out a good deal of his skills, he just has to hope the one thing he's worked on his whole career is enough for him.
Basically, put a boxing guy in a MMA fight and he's under prepared but he still has a distinct advantage in one facet of the game, striking, and he has a chance at using that to get a win, an early KO being the easiest way. But an MMA guy has to be a jack of all trades, more or less, so put him in a boxing ring with boxing rules and he has no advantages cause a boxing guy has obviously trained boxing much more than an MMA guy.
Didn't Mercer get beat by Kimbo of all people?
Last edited by OumaFan; 07-22-2009 at 01:51 AM.
when people that have no previous experience in professional combat sports, Bob Sapp, Lesnar, Lashley, etc., go on to become "real threats" and have "lucrative" careers in the sport, well it doesn't say much good, and yea that's 1 former pro football/part time actor, and 2 former WWE wrestlers
Problem with Syvia is he always fought like he thought he was a boxer. His ground game pretty much sucked, and his takedown "defense" was his size. The UFC HW division was weaker than boxing's and Couture had to come back to whoop him; then Brock, then Mercer.
I had forgot about his fight with Mercer being basically a boxing match; but it wouldn't have matterd because Tim still would have fought him like a boxer and not attemptd to take him down, so he'd of lost anyways. Tim always fought that way and was garbage.
Dana White is not well liked by the masses, but he is a smart, smart dude. He is a fabulous promoter who has the balls to call it like he sees it and speak his mind, and I think he's right on the money with what he said about boxing and Floyd.
Hidden Content
That's the way it is, not the way it ends
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks