Hopkins wants the winner of Dawson - Johnson

[CFH]

I think Dawson should beat Hopkins and that Hopkins should get old at some point, but the first Johnson fight showed that Dawson was a sucker for the right hand and that he could be hurt. Hopkins has one of the best right hands in the game and Dawson's volume could play into his counter-punching style. However, Calzaghe showed what a good workrate could do against Hopkins as well. It would really be a pick'em fight in my mind. I'd lean towards Dawson though.

I think Hopkins would beat Johnson in a fight that no one would give a shit about.

[killersheep]

I think Dawson should beat Hopkins and that Hopkins should get old at some point, but the first Johnson fight showed that Dawson was a sucker for the right hand and that he could be hurt. Hopkins has one of the best right hands in the game and Dawson's volume could play into his counter-punching style. However, Calzaghe showed what a good workrate could do against Hopkins as well. It would really be a pick'em fight in my mind. I'd lean towards Dawson though.

I think Hopkins would beat Johnson in a fight that no one would give a shit about.

I would love to see Johnson/Hopkins it would be interesting to see how much has changed since the first time they met in the ring so many years ago. I have no problem with either fight being made, but I would like to see Hopkins take at least a tune-up between now and April of next year (which is when the fight would most likely happen)

[CFH]

I think Dawson should beat Hopkins and that Hopkins should get old at some point, but the first Johnson fight showed that Dawson was a sucker for the right hand and that he could be hurt. Hopkins has one of the best right hands in the game and Dawson's volume could play into his counter-punching style. However, Calzaghe showed what a good workrate could do against Hopkins as well. It would really be a pick'em fight in my mind. I'd lean towards Dawson though.

I think Hopkins would beat Johnson in a fight that no one would give a shit about.

I would love to see Johnson/Hopkins it would be interesting to see how much has changed since the first time they met in the ring so many years ago. I have no problem with either fight being made, but I would like to see Hopkins take at least a tune-up between now and April of next year (which is when the fight would most likely happen)

Really? I'd (obviously) watch it, but that fight doesn't appeal to me nearly as much as Dawson - Hopkins and I don't know that it would capture peoples attention in the same way that fight would. I like Johnson and I'd be happy to see him get the payday, but I'd much rather see Dawson in his place.

[ClubberLang]

I don't see how this fight does anything for Hopkins. A win does little for his legacy. At this point, it seems to me the only fights worth taking for him are ones that will enhance his legacy. I think he should take the Adamek fight. It would give him the legit championship in a third weight class. I think it is also a more winnable fight than with Dawson. Dawson is too fast for Hopkins at his age. Adamek would be similar to Pavlik, a slow, one dimensional plodder who Hopkins should be able to out skill if he can handle the weight increase.

[killersheep]

I don't see how this fight does anything for Hopkins. A win does little for his legacy. At this point, it seems to me the only fights worth taking for him are ones that will enhance his legacy. I think he should take the Adamek fight. It would give him the legit championship in a third weight class. I think it is also a more winnable fight than with Dawson. Dawson is too fast for Hopkins at his age. Adamek would be similar to Pavlik, a slow, one dimensional plodder who Hopkins should be able to out skill if he can handle the weight increase.

Really? I think this is a very meaningful fight for Hopkins, he will be fight todays best Light Heavyweight, so either he proves he's still the best or passes the torch. I think should he win it will definitely add an important name to his legacy. As for Adamek that would be a great fight as well, but I don't know if Hopkins could make weight, he has to work very hard to get up to 175.

[ClubberLang]

I don't see how this fight does anything for Hopkins. A win does little for his legacy. At this point, it seems to me the only fights worth taking for him are ones that will enhance his legacy. I think he should take the Adamek fight. It would give him the legit championship in a third weight class. I think it is also a more winnable fight than with Dawson. Dawson is too fast for Hopkins at his age. Adamek would be similar to Pavlik, a slow, one dimensional plodder who Hopkins should be able to out skill if he can handle the weight increase.

Really? I think this is a very meaningful fight for Hopkins, he will be fight todays best Light Heavyweight, so either he proves he's still the best or passes the torch. I think should he win it will definitely add an important name to his legacy. As for Adamek that would be a great fight as well, but I don't know if Hopkins could make weight, he has to work very hard to get up to 175.

Yeah, but Hopkins already got his "old-man-schooling-the-young-lion" cred by whipping Pavlik. Trying to do that again with Dawson would just be covering old ground, a win would be impressive certainly but I don't think would add much to his legacy, especially compared to the Adamek fight which would give him a legit title in another division.

[killersheep]

I don't see how this fight does anything for Hopkins. A win does little for his legacy. At this point, it seems to me the only fights worth taking for him are ones that will enhance his legacy. I think he should take the Adamek fight. It would give him the legit championship in a third weight class. I think it is also a more winnable fight than with Dawson. Dawson is too fast for Hopkins at his age. Adamek would be similar to Pavlik, a slow, one dimensional plodder who Hopkins should be able to out skill if he can handle the weight increase.

Really? I think this is a very meaningful fight for Hopkins, he will be fight todays best Light Heavyweight, so either he proves he's still the best or passes the torch. I think should he win it will definitely add an important name to his legacy. As for Adamek that would be a great fight as well, but I don't know if Hopkins could make weight, he has to work very hard to get up to 175.

Yeah, but Hopkins already got his "old-man-schooling-the-young-lion" cred by whipping Pavlik. Trying to do that again with Dawson would just be covering old ground, a win would be impressive certainly but I don't think would add much to his legacy, especially compared to the Adamek fight which would give him a legit title in another division.

Agree to disagree, no problem....I just think that Dawson is a totally different animal than Pavlik. I just think the weight differential to Cruiser is too great which is why he didn't go through with the Adamek fight before. Another 25 pounds up at his age will be difficult, and while Adamek is a stalking fighter he has more tools than Pavlik. I have no problem with the fight Hopkins is taking, I look forward to it either way be it Dawson (with handspeed equal to Calzaghe's) or Johnson (whom he has a lot of shared history with)