Who was the better fighter and who has left the better legacy behind ?

[Kel]

Tito, not by a huge margin but clearly Tito.

[God.in.my.corner]

Tito due to his competiton.

[Hulk]

Tito Trinidad. No doubt.

Aside from the fighters mentioned, he also beat Yory Boy Campas at a time when I believe Campas was at 55-0 (53 KO's) or somethin crazy like that.

Tito was a phenom.

[Majesty]

Not Kostya's fight that no one wanted to fight him at 140 now is it?

[BIG H]

1996
Feb. 10 -- Rodney Moore, Las Vegas, Nevada, TKO 4
(Retained IBF welterweight title)
May 18 -- Freddie Pendleton, Las Vegas, Nevada, KO 5
(Retained IBF welterweight title)
Sep. 7 -- Ray Lovato, Las Vegas, Nevada, TKO 6
(Retained IBF welterweight title)

1997
Jan. 11 -- Kevin Leushing, Nashville, Tennessee, TKO 3
(Retained IBF welterweight title)
Aug. 23 -- Troy Waters, New York City, KO 1

1998
Apr. 3 -- Mahenge Zulu, Bayamon, Puerto Rico, KO 4
(Retained IBF welterweight title)

1999
Feb. 20 -- Pernell Whitaker, New York, W 12
(Retained IBF welterweight title)
May 29 -- Hugo Pineda, San Juan, Puerto Rico, KO 4
(Retained IBF welterweight title)
Sep. 18 -- Oscar de la Hoya, Las Vegas, W 12
(Retained IBF welterweight title)
(Captured WBC welterweight title)

2000
Mar. 3 -- David Reid, Las Vegas, Nevada, W 12
(Captured WBA super welterweight title)
July 22 -- Mamadou Thiam, Miami, Florida, TKO 3
(Retained WBA super welterweight title)
Dec. 2 -- Fernando Vargas, Las Vegas, Nevada, TKO 12
(Retained WBA super welterweight title)
(Captured IBF junior middleweight title)

2001
May 12 -- William Joppy, New York, New York, TKO 5
(Captured WBA middleweight title)
Sept. 29 -- Bernard Hopkins, New York, New York, TKO by 12
(Lost WBA middleweight title)
(For WBC and IBF middleweight title)

2002
May 11 -- Hacine Cherifi, San Juan, Puerto Rico, TKO 4

2004
Oct. 2 -- Ricardo Mayorga, New York, NY, TKO 8

2005
May 14 -- Winky Wright, Las Vegas,


Definatley alot of fillers in there but not too shabby!
Neither was Tszyu but i would of liked to have seen more from Kostya specially a rematch of Phillips.

Lol - but he lost to 3 of the 6 you named

[Jody Lane]

I gotta go with Trinidad too. Only thing I can say for KT is he didn't continue this stupid back and forth back and forth retirement deal that Felix did that netted losses to Wright and Jones.

[holmcall]

Kosya Tysyu because he stayed retired and didn't make a fool out of himself like Tito did against Roy. On the other hand, going out on a stool is not the greatest thing either.