Even if Floyd was to beat De la Hoya Taylor would still be my #1 p4p.

Taylor did not wait for challenges he went out and got them
Taylor did not use his stature after winning 2 big fights vs Bernard Hopkins to fight some shmoe
Taylor is younger and has already fought tougher fighters than Floyd

I'm not dissing Floyd but he has to actively seek out challenges, if he's so good why doesn't he show us by beating people that we want to see him fight: Margarito, Hatton, Cotto instead of fighting Zab Judah and Sharmba Mitchell.