Poll: Fantasy Super Six SMW

[Kev]

I'll go with Calzaghe, man didn't know how to lose.

B Hop would claim he won though.

[ryanman]

I'll go with Calzaghe, man didn't know how to lose.

B Hop would claim he won though.

touche Bilbo.

[jon09]

Well since you put at their peak then Roy would have won hands down. Him and Calzaghe would have probably been the final with a bit of controversy along the way.

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

The Roy Jones/ Bernard Hopkins that Decked Calzaghe in the 1st round of their fight would of embarrassed Calzaghe.

[iwng100]

Roy Jones in his prime would have lost less than 5 cumulated rounds in the entire tournament.

[Truth]

BHop would be best equipped to win in a tournament format because of his safe fighting style and ability to control fights. Jones will probably be the popular choice for this but in a 6 man tournament his chin would get craccked by BHop or someone else. Seeing that BHop should've beaten Calzaghe @ 43 he would've disposed of him. I don't thnk MCLellan, Benn or Eubank have much of a chance against the big 3 but any of them could catch Roy.

[thewhale]

Roy Jones Jr. I only needed like half a second to be sure. What a turney that would be, at least we can dream about it

[ryanman]

BHop would be best equipped to win in a tournament format because of his safe fighting style and ability to control fights. Jones will probably be the popular choice for this but in a 6 man tournament his chin would get craccked by BHop or someone else. Seeing that BHop should've beaten Calzaghe @ 43 he would've disposed of him. I don't thnk MCLellan, Benn or Eubank have much of a chance against the big 3 but any of them could catch Roy.

Your presumption here is that an ageing Hopkins almost beat a PEAK Calzaghe. This is wrong. Calzaghe was some way past his peak also. Plus it was a poor performance by Calzaghe even by the standards of being past his peak. In reality a past-his-peak Calzaghe narrowly beat a past-his-peak Hopkins.