
Originally Posted by
ElTerribleMorales

Originally Posted by
Puerto Rican Punch
Lets revisit the definition of not dominating fighter based on some Tito's highlights:
Welter weight champ from 1993 until 1999 when he decided moving to 154 after defeating De La Hoya to defeat an undefeated champ, former gold medalist (Reid), the reason why he did not fight Mosley or Forest. During his period at 147 he beat people like Campas (56-0), Carr (32-0), De La Hoya. With very few exeptions most of his opponents had good records, thus he fought the best of the division during his time. And we are not talking about heavy weights, there is quality in these divisions.
We can argue that De La Hoya was a very close fight and perhaps De La Hoya could win (or could get KO) if he had more heart to fight and less mouth. To speak a little about gifts we can mention his "victory" over a Whitaker in a similar shape than the one that Tito clearly beat (don't want to mention other De La Hoya's gift such as Sturm).
From 1999 to 2001 fought De La Hoya (31-0), Reid (14-0), Thiam (33-1), Vargas (20-0), Joppy (32-1), Hopkins (39-2); 6 fight, 1 mandatory, 5 world champs and beat 4 of them, they had a combined record of 169 wins with only 4 losses. Not bad for a non-dominating fighter...

De La Hoya has never been one to really run his mouth and talk crap about his opponents, Trinidad did plenty of it and the person who tries to deny it, well i have plenty cut outs of his big fights in the past, not that most of it wasn't backed up but he talked plenty shit, no way in hell was DLH gonna get KO'd by Trinidad, if anything it would have been the other way around, Oscar/Tito wasn't a close fight, DLH won the first 9 straight, and there was no knockdowns, DLH beat Whitaker in a close fight, plenty pick that as a reasonable call, i had Oscar beating Whitaker 115-113, Sturm is the only really bad decision on his record, i had Sturm winning 115-113 or even 116-112, and that was already when DLH was out of his element at 160, do i need to remind you about what happened to Trinidad after the Joppy fight?
he got KO'd by B-Hop, beat a very weak Cherriffi (spelling?), retired, came back beat a Mayorga who had never fought above 147, then got schooled by Wright, then embarrassed he retired again, only to comeback and get schooled by an old merciful Jones, he could have KO'd Trinidad at any point after the 6th, again i'm not downplaying any of Trinidad's SUCCESS but he was never a Hopkins, Calzaghe, or Jones in ANY DIVISION he fought in
Now I can understand better; we are just talking about 2 different Trinidad because I don't recall that trash talking that you are mentioning here in his career. I believe me. I followed Felix "Tito" Trinidad career (the one from Puerto Rico). One thing is confidence and stating that he was going to win (what my Trinidad did) vs the talk crap that the Trinidad you are refering to did. I don't think you got my point, when I said that De La Hoya needed less mouth
and more heart, I was refering to the fact that De La Hoya all the time said that he wanted the rematch, but never stepped in the ring with Tito again. I was not saying that De La Hoya was insulting anyone. If there are no possibility that Tito could KO him, just asked yourself why De La Hoya decided to start running a marathon instead of stopping and KO Tito
We can certainly differ in opinions of who won, Tito or De La Hoya. This is why this forum is so intersting where we can share different opinions and point of views. But if you think that De La Hoya won all first 9 rounds and I really can question this judgment as being partial. So it really does not mean anything to me.
And, no I had not forgot what happened after Joppys fight, that is why I am saying that from 1999 to 2001 Tito fought 5 world champs and beat 4 of them. Just tell how many boxers can say this? Just a few, right? But I can also remember what happened during Joppy's fight and all the previous fights.
Being an undefeated champ for 6 year before unifying at 147, then quickly move to the upper divisions to unify titles at 154 beating to undefeated champs, and crush a solid champ at 160 before being stopped... and this is non a dominating fighter...
what a contradiction. But as I said we can have different opinions and this is why this is so interesting.
Bookmarks