B Hop is Overrated

[OumaFan]

I don't have a problem with saying Roy had better comp, he probably did although he had a whole lot of nobodies but he didn't have far better comp. A couple of those Hall of Fame wins weren't really big wins, even though he still knew what he was doing that was an old and way past his best weight McCallum and much more so in Paz' case. Montell Griffin was a better win than those. That and Winky is a HOFer for what its worth.

Bit of an aside but I wouldn't rule out Tarver for the Hall.

[JonesJrMayweather]

[quote=OumaFan;777033]I don't have a problem with saying Roy had better comp, he probably did although he had a whole lot of nobodies but he didn't have far better comp. A couple of those Hall of Fame wins weren't really big wins, even though he still knew what he was doing that was an old and way past his best weight McCallum and much more so in Paz' case. Montell Griffin was a better win than those. That and Winky is a HOFer for what its worth.

Bit of an aside but I wouldn't rule out Tarver for the Hall. [/quote]

Then so are Rahman and McCall.

[OumaFan]

Nah, there are guys in the hall that don't have better than Jones X 2, Glen Johnson once (probably should have been twice), Montell Griffin, Eric Harding. Well and Eric Harding. Not many but I can think of a few. He's also only lost to really good fighters. Well, and Eric Harding, a good fighter at the time.

I'm not nominating him. Don't think he should get in. But just saying, stranger things have happened.