Bradley - Campbell decision overturned

[CFH]

Judges and referees are part of the fight, just like in football and basketball.


What will you do if the fight was stopped prematurely by a ref bec. he sensed the boxer will be hurt and that boxer filed for a reversal of decision siting he is fit to continue but was not given the opportuniy to do so?




_____

That is in no way relevant to this discussion really. If a fighter protested a stoppage, it would have to be an incredibly obviously fraudulent move by the ref for the commission to even consider it and if that was the case I would hope that they did look into it. The two situations are in no way related other than that they both pertain to boxing.

[spade]

Judges and referees are part of the fight, just like in football and basketball.


What will you do if the fight was stopped prematurely by a ref bec. he sensed the boxer will be hurt and that boxer filed for a reversal of decision siting he is fit to continue but was not given the opportuniy to do so?




_____

That is in no way relevant to this discussion really. If a fighter protested a stoppage, it would have to be an incredibly obviously fraudulent move by the ref for the commission to even consider it and if that was the case I would hope that they did look into it. The two situations are in no way related other than that they both pertain to boxing.

Mate i got your point that this is an exceptional case and my concern is not related to this fight but i'm talking in general.

What should we do to the ref then who failed to see the real situation? Hey it's not your your fault that we reversed the decision because you get it wrong.

I agree with the Commission on this one but not on general fight that lasted the whole 12 rounds.


___

[CFH]

Judges and referees are part of the fight, just like in football and basketball.


What will you do if the fight was stopped prematurely by a ref bec. he sensed the boxer will be hurt and that boxer filed for a reversal of decision siting he is fit to continue but was not given the opportuniy to do so?




_____

That is in no way relevant to this discussion really. If a fighter protested a stoppage, it would have to be an incredibly obviously fraudulent move by the ref for the commission to even consider it and if that was the case I would hope that they did look into it. The two situations are in no way related other than that they both pertain to boxing.

Mate i got your point that this is an exceptional case and my concern is not related to this fight but i'm talking in general.

What should we do to the ref then who failed to see the real situation? Hey it's not your your fault that we reversed the decision because you get it wrong.

I agree with the Commission on this one but not on general fight that lasted the whole 12 rounds.


___

But the two situations cannot really be compared. They're completely dissimilar.