Cotto? He lost to Cotto and I don't think that has any bearing on who the champion is anyways, just how someone would be ranked had they not been champion.

Are you sure Mosley was 3rd? If anything their real mistake would have been ranking a Mosley ahead of Cotto, that doesn't seem like it could be right and that's probably what the deal was. I have the issue prior I'll see if I can dig it out.