Quote Originally Posted by raleights
Will someone explain to me why MAB would be ahead of Joe Calzaghe? He struggled with Rocky, will more than likely get destroyed by Pac if it happens again. Just a bit confused on that one..
MAB has beaten more A grade fighters than JC,has a great trilogy,multiple weight champ,front foot and back foot fighter,brilliant D etc etc You can't just base positions from MAB's last fight. and I am a JC fan so I'm not being biased.It may or may not be Joe's fault but his level of overall competition is nowhere near Mab's:Hamed,EM,Pac,Juarez,Junior Jones,Mckinnedy etc etc. JC is great though but I don't think he should be high than MAB.

Quote Originally Posted by MRMANICK
My list:

1-pbf
2-pac man
3-winky wright
4-bernard hopkins
5-R.Marquez
6-barrera
7-hatton
8-joe c
9- j taylor
10-arce

I put pac ahead of wright cause i don't think him beating the smaller mosley and the semi-retired trinidad is all that but he hasn't lost in a while. The only reason i got jt up there is cause in a sense i have too. I can't take the W away from him even though i don't think he deserved it. But in a pound for pound sense i can see him losing to alot of people.I would have hatton lower too but he has fought 3 title fights in a row. Even though i think maussa and collazo(i feel collazo won) are weak opponents he did win.Joe only gets on cause of his longevity. I think most of his opponents were weak including lacy but he is undefeated and has defended his paper title 17 times so i have too.I love arce. If he fights and beats martin castillo i would bump him up like 3 spaces.Hes been undefeated for a while now and has fought a lot of game fighters. I respect that. Well thats my list. Some may like it some may not but i think its fair.
Not a bad list but I just can't put B Hop that high as his record in the last 3 fights include 2 losses so to have him higher than JT would feel weird,and I have Winky at number for great wins and P4P,I don't see anyone beating that style and when he beats JT,he will consolidate that.I like that you have Arce and Marquez there though.I wouldn't have Rafael that high yet though,he needs some more big fights.
Bilbo,that's what I am saying,B Hop lost the fights rather than JT winning them.Had Hop gone full throttle,we would still be calling him P4P number 1 right now.