He's retired and I wanted to keep the discussion to fighters still fighting, but Calzaghe would have laid to rest any doubt on his standing if he had fought and beat a prime Chad Dawson. Not that I doubt his standing amongst the greats, but some people did, and a win over a prime Bad Chad one division up from where he fought his whole career would have cemented him as an ATG.

On that note, I'd like to see Floyd fight Shane and Paul Williams. Beating them would do a lot for his standing too. Moreso than beating Pacquiao in my book.

Both Floyd and Joe never lost a fight and suffer the same criticism. Both are fighters who could lay it to rest by taking one or two more fights.