is Winky P4P with a solid win?

[Taeth]

I don't think Winky should be placed ahead of PBF until PBF loses.

[frozensolid_702]

If Winky wins this one in a impressive fashion then he may well have claim to P4P....for me though PBF is until someone kicks his a***....which i dont see happening for a long time.

Nor do I but he hasnt faced much comp recently . Look at the guys hes fought . None of them have beenp4p material . The best hes fought is Judah nd even he is a chinny fighter who was coming off a loss to a nobody .

who should he have fought??
hattons scared..........
dont even start with margarito until he fights somebody decent................
zab was kinda the man until he blew it with baldomir and they had the april 8th fight set at the thomas and mack before zab even fought carlos............
he fought mitchell (2nd best ww southpaw behind zab at the time..brilliant move for floyd in spite of the criticism from the uneducated)
chop-chop was vastly under-rated............
now he wants oscar....
hes number 1 until he loses........deal with it

[GAME]

If Winky wins this one in a impressive fashion then he may well have claim to P4P....for me though PBF is until someone kicks his a***....which i dont see happening for a long time.

Nor do I but he hasnt faced much comp recently . Look at the guys hes fought . None of them have beenp4p material . The best hes fought is Judah nd even he is a chinny fighter who was coming off a loss to a nobody .

who should he have fought??
hattons scared..........
dont even start with margarito until he fights somebody decent................
zab was kinda the man until he blew it with baldomir and they had the april 8th fight set at the thomas and mack before zab even fought carlos............
he fought mitchell (2nd best ww southpaw behind zab at the time..brilliant move for floyd in spite of the criticism from the uneducated)
chop-chop was vastly under-rated............
now he wants oscar....
hes number 1 until he loses........deal with it

Casamayor , Freitas . JLC beat him at lightweight but didnt get the decision , Hatton , Cotto

Any of those wuda been better than Brussels , Mitchel etc