The only people lying to themselves are the naive few who think Roy, let alone any fighter, in his prime had a style that would shut out everyone. Sorry, but that's not the case. You're damn right Tarver's style would give Roy problems no matter when they fought. And like I said before, you'd have a much better argument if Roy would have gotten KO'd in his first fight with Tarver, but he didn't, he won it outright, fair and square. He got KTFO in the rematch. Doesn't bode to well for Roy supporters saying he was 'over the hill.' lol