Quote Originally Posted by skel1983 View Post
Quote Originally Posted by Bilbo View Post
I find it laughable really. Holyfield, Ruiz and Chagaev all beat Valuev as well or better than Haye.

Valuev has only fought four fighters of any note, lost to all and Haye probably did the worst.

All he demonstrated is he's roughly at the same level as an almost 50 year old Evander and John Ruiz.
So going off your theory, that Mayweather is around about the same level as Cory Spinks and is inferior to Miguel Cotto, Kosta Tszyu and Joshua Clottey as they all beat Zab Judah in better fashion
Mayweather beat Judah much better than Spinks did. Spinks was ko'd in the second fight and only barely survived the 12th round in the first.

As for Floyd against Cotto, Tszyu and Clottey we wouldn't know because Floyd doesn't fight people in the same weight class as him.