I see what you are saying Jaz, but they were 2 completely different fights and unless they were exactly the same that there can be different levels of crapness and different winners. I don't see why somebody couldn't pick Haye and Froch (I picked Haye and Dirrell) Froch did not throw/miss exactly the same amount of punches in all of the same rounds as Valuev, the fights can be scored differently.