Is Nonito Donaire really the 6th best boxer in the world??

[ElTerribleMorales]

OK gonna have to ban Bilbo from this thread

The more talented parts obviously more subjective, I definitely wouldn't put Caballero above him in that category and I think Caballero at 8 is an all time WTF moment. And this is coming from somebody who kind of championed Caballero for a while when he was unknown or underrated. He is NOT one of the ten best fighters in the world IMO, no way. I think Donaire could be but his resume doesn't match up yet.

Right now I'd say Caballero is the more talented fighter. Still I agree he's not Top 10 p4p.

I don't Donaire has the potential to be, but you can't have people in there off potential.

Anyway you can't ban Bilbo, think of his delight when he finally sees we agree on something, although no doubt he will take it too far & start ranting about midgets getting benefits in the p4p rankings

IMO neither Donaire, Juanma Lopez, Gamboa, or Caballero have done enough to be p4p, and with that said Caballero's done the most out of the bunch