Is Nonito Donaire really the 6th best boxer in the world??

[CFH]

Donaire is a really good fighter, and people need to stop caring about what someone has done and just analyze how good somebody is. I knew Floyd was better than Bernard Hopkins before he got the p4p title just because of how he fought and how good he was. That's why when there are two prospects we just know who is likely to be better than who, and thats what the p4p rankings are all about.

That's an incredibly subjective way to categorize a fighter. I think skills should weight into P4P rankings, but more so I think a fighters record and consistency should be what matter most. Either way, P4P lists are useless in my opinion, far too subjective.

[amat]

Taeth is somewhat right, imo. I think there is definitely an argument to be made that Nonito is one of the most 10 most talented fighters in the game. He's DEFINITELY more skilled then Celestino Caballero.

Buuuut if you asked me my list of the most talented fighters in boxing, guys like Joan Guzman would be on there when their accomplishments clearly don't merit that sort of recognition. There has to be a balance.