Is Nonito Donaire really the 6th best boxer in the world??

[Kev]

Ah FINALLY somebody else agrees with on this!. Nonito has done NOTHING to merit p4p status, he's beaten a guy in Darchinyan who is probably on the level of a Humberto Soto, a guy that Juan Guzman beat with ease.

Comparing the rest of Guzman's career to Donaires there is no comparison, Donaire has fought NOBODY!!! He almost got beat last time out by a 13-3-1 club fighter.

He's not even top 20 p4p, and will fall faster than you can say 'Mijares' when he actually fights somebody half decent.

As Johnny Perez has now beaten the man who beat the man who the man beat surely he should be p4p top 5 now right?

It's fucking ludicrous and I will tell you why this happens. It's positive discrimination in which the Ring Magazine openly gives benefits to the midgets in their p4p rankings.......

[JazMerkin]

Ah FINALLY somebody else agrees with on this!. Nonito has done NOTHING to merit p4p status, he's beaten a guy in Darchinyan who is probably on the level of a Humberto Soto, a guy that Juan Guzman beat with ease.

Comparing the rest of Guzman's career to Donaires there is no comparison, Donaire has fought NOBODY!!! He almost got beat last time out by a 13-3-1 club fighter.

He's not even top 20 p4p, and will fall faster than you can say 'Mijares' when he actually fights somebody half decent.

As Johnny Perez has now beaten the man who beat the man who the man beat surely he should be p4p top 5 now right?

It's fucking ludicrous and I will tell you why this happens. It's positive discrimination in which the Ring Magazine openly gives benefits to the midgets in their p4p rankings.......

Darchinyan is nowhere near as good as Soto imo, Soto has just had a tougher road to the top & Guzman was a bad style matchup.

I disagree with your last bit (c'mon Bilbo you know I have to), but you're right Donaire has done little to justify his placement on the list & if we are doing it purely off talent as Taeth suggests, I gave a list of fighters at least some of whom are more talented. Are we really saying that only Mayweather, Pacquiao, Mosley, Hopkins & Marquez are better fighters?

[sumkalambay]

Ah FINALLY somebody else agrees with on this!. Nonito has done NOTHING to merit p4p status, he's beaten a guy in Darchinyan who is probably on the level of a Humberto Soto, a guy that Juan Guzman beat with ease.

Comparing the rest of Guzman's career to Donaires there is no comparison, Donaire has fought NOBODY!!! He almost got beat last time out by a 13-3-1 club fighter.

He's not even top 20 p4p, and will fall faster than you can say 'Mijares' when he actually fights somebody half decent.

As Johnny Perez has now beaten the man who beat the man who the man beat surely he should be p4p top 5 now right?

It's fucking ludicrous and I will tell you why this happens. It's positive discrimination in which the Ring Magazine openly gives benefits to the midgets in their p4p rankings.......

what a truly fuking awful post this is... darchinyan is on the level of humberto soto? what the hell are you talking about?

how many donaire/darchinyan fights have you seen? do you even follow these divisions?

lmao at rafael concepcion almost beating donaire. the dude came in with a significant weight advantage and donaire injured his hand in that fight. and donaire still won convincingly.

as for the thread, no i don't believe donaire is top 10 p4p.

[Kev]

Ah FINALLY somebody else agrees with on this!. Nonito has done NOTHING to merit p4p status, he's beaten a guy in Darchinyan who is probably on the level of a Humberto Soto, a guy that Juan Guzman beat with ease.

Comparing the rest of Guzman's career to Donaires there is no comparison, Donaire has fought NOBODY!!! He almost got beat last time out by a 13-3-1 club fighter.

He's not even top 20 p4p, and will fall faster than you can say 'Mijares' when he actually fights somebody half decent.

As Johnny Perez has now beaten the man who beat the man who the man beat surely he should be p4p top 5 now right?

It's fucking ludicrous and I will tell you why this happens. It's positive discrimination in which the Ring Magazine openly gives benefits to the midgets in their p4p rankings.......

what a truly fuking awful post this is... darchinyan is on the level of humberto soto? what the hell are you talking about?

how many donaire/darchinyan fights have you seen? do you even follow these divisions?

lmao at rafael concepcion almost beating donaire. the dude came in with a significant weight advantage and donaire injured his hand in that fight. and donaire still won convincingly.

as for the thread, no i don't believe donaire is top 10 p4p.

So you are suggesting Darchinyan is significantly better than Humberto Soto?

I disagree, as I suspect will most....