I spent five painstaking months coming up with this P4P list. I'm Ouma the Daddy.

[ICB]

Its the first one I've made in like half a decade. The first two are interchangeable really and then its a crap shoot. As said in another thread some is based on achievements, some on perceived ability, some on personal bias

1)Manny Pacquaio
2)Floyd Mayweather
3)Juan Manuel Marquez
4)Bernard Hopkins
5)Miguel Cotto
6)Shane Mosley
7)Chad Dawson
Ivan Calderon
9)Paul Williams
10)Arthur Abraham

Just missed the cut
Izzy Vazquez
Rafa Marquez-see above, they're both old, not sure what they have left and inactive, both looked bad last time out, if they come back looking good they could both be back in.
Hozumi Hasegawa
Nonito Donaire
Mikkel Kessler
Kelly Pavlik
Fernando Montiel
Vic Darchinyan

and some other guys, tired of mentioning them

LOL no way you're a part of my list

Wlad
Vitali
Froch

It may be bad but its pretty definitive

1 Floyd Mayweather Jr
2 Manny Pacquiao
3 Juan Manuel Marquez
4 Bernard Hopkins
5 Miguel Cotto
6 Shane Mosley
7 Chad Dawson
8 Paul Williams
9 Celestino Caballero
10 Arthur Abraham

[Kev]

Its the first one I've made in like half a decade. The first two are interchangeable really and then its a crap shoot. As said in another thread some is based on achievements, some on perceived ability, some on personal bias

1)Manny Pacquaio
2)Floyd Mayweather
3)Juan Manuel Marquez
4)Bernard Hopkins
5)Miguel Cotto
6)Shane Mosley
7)Chad Dawson
Ivan Calderon
9)Paul Williams
10)Arthur Abraham

Just missed the cut
Izzy Vazquez
Rafa Marquez-see above, they're both old, not sure what they have left and inactive, both looked bad last time out, if they come back looking good they could both be back in.
Hozumi Hasegawa
Nonito Donaire
Mikkel Kessler
Kelly Pavlik
Fernando Montiel
Vic Darchinyan

and some other guys, tired of mentioning them

LOL no way you're a part of my list

Wlad
Vitali
Froch

It may be bad but its pretty definitive

1 Floyd Mayweather Jr
2 Manny Pacquiao
3 Juan Manuel Marquez
4 Bernard Hopkins
5 Miguel Cotto
6 Shane Mosley
7 Chad Dawson
8 Paul Williams
9 Celestino Caballero
10 Arthur Abraham

I like ICB's list. We can quibble over whether Mosely should be above Cotto, but its generally which side you come down on, Cotto's for beating Mosely on points in a close fight, or Mosely for destroying the guy who destroyed Cotto.

But either way this list is reasonable and makes sense. I don't know a great deal about Cabellero so can't really comment, but the Ring likes him and he's not Nonito Donaire so it's all good.

Best p4p rankings I've seen on here.