I think Gerhart would deserve it over Ingram but his team wasn't undefeated and he wasn't a catalyst in beating Tebow. I guess it's just because Richardson got his share against Auburn. Tebow and McCoy have played themselves out of it, though McCoy winning wouldn't bother me. If you want to give it to the best player in the country, why not give it to Suh? It would be badass if he won (more badass then Woodson sticking it in the face of Manning, still remember that, that was before I developed my intense hatred of the big 10.)