OK so PAC is easily Fighter of the year.

[killersheep]

The official result is very important. Can you name a "fighter of the year" who lost during the year?

Also regarding Froch-Dirrell, most influential boxing journalists had the fight very close either way, not a robbery

Dan Rafael - ESPN
Doug Fischer - The Ring
Graham Huston - Boxing Monthly
Thomas Hauser - Seconds Out
Steve Bunce - Bunce Boxing

All said it was NO robbery

can you name a fighter of the year who's biggest win was a controversial decision in his own hometown?

Nope. As far as Froch is concerned, he was in Taylor's backyard when he scored his biggest win. I don't think anyone thinks Froch is "fighter of the year" though.

I'm thinking Tam may disagree