I still favor Vitali over Haye.

Vitali didn't look so great against Johnson but that was because Johnson threw literally no punches and was only concerned with defending himself than actually trying to win.

It's hard to look impressive against a fighter like that.

From what i remember, Vitali did look old against Gomez as well. Gomez was a fighter with superior speed and movement.

Vitali at this point is more impressive and dominant against pressure fighters (Peter, Arreola) but fighters who have superior speed and use movement ( Gomez, Johnson) will trouble him more. The funny thing is, Vitali didn't look dominate against Gomez or Johnson but if you watch both fights, he clearly won every round against both.

Haye has both good movement and superior speed but his chin isn't good at all, I see Vitali catching him and getting him out of there.

One problem i do have with Vitali is how he throws punches now. His punches don't have the snap on them like they used to because he throws arm punches.