Calling All Beatles Fans - Saddo Boxing Beatles Discussion Thread!!

[lamble39]

Yeah the medley's fantastic. Awesome drum solo! Dunno about you but I find that you can't listen to one segment. The whole medley has to go on! And did you know that 'Her Majesty' was originally going to be put somewhere else in the medley? hence the gap and sudden big note to enter it.

[BIG H]

Yeah the medley's fantastic. Awesome drum solo! Dunno about you but I find that you can't listen to one segment. The whole medley has to go on! And did you know that 'Her Majesty' was originally going to be put somewhere else in the medley? hence the gap and sudden big note to enter it.

Yeh, pretty sure I read it was going to go between Mr Mustard & Polythene Pam

[OumaFan]

Revolver is IMO the best Beatles album. So tight, no filler, just good stuff. What an album should be.

I like the White Album, a lot really, but they are kind of masturbating all over themselves with that one. Could have been tightened up. Plus too many songs about raccoons and bluebirds.

[BIG H]

Revolver is IMO the best Beatles album. So tight, no filler, just good stuff. What an album should be.

I like the White Album, a lot really, but they are kind of masturbating all over themselves with that one. Could have been tightened up. Plus too many songs about raccoons and bluebirds.

.... and Monkey's fucking in the road

[Andre]

When you think about it all their albums were like artists paintings.

Where as most plod along with their comfortable and known medium the Beatles really did more exploring than most others for that time I like that their albums vary more than most other bands from back then.

[Andre]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z59Ht...eature=related

Nice quality here.

[BIG H]

Good tune that Andre - written in Marakesh about Prudence Farrow

[Gandalf]

When you think about it all their albums were like artists paintings.

Where as most plod along with their comfortable and known medium the Beatles really did more exploring than most others for that time I like that their albums vary more than most other bands from back then.

That's true. You really get a sense of progression in the early albums and a greater sense of stylistic variation as they advanced in their career. That's one of the reasons I am such a fan of Bowie's '70's output too. You get a real sense that pop music is being taken somewhere new album by album. It's something that seems to get harder and harder for artists to do. I suppose Radiohead have come the closest in recent years, but I personally feel that some of their more recent albums have had their share of slack moments and it takes them so much longer, so I guess the comparisons end there. I really admire the older artists that could be consistent and do it on a yearly basis.

[BIG H]

After much deliberation I have come up with the folloiwng ranking for the Beatles albums. It's probably not what most people would agree with (e.g A Hard Day's Night being so high up and The White Album being so low down) but this is how I see it

1.) Revolver
2.) Abbey Road
3.) A Hard Day's Night
4.) Magical Mystery Tour
5.) Sgt Pepper
6.) Help
7.) Let It Be
8.) Please Please Me
9.) The White Album
10.) Beatles For Sale
11.) With The Beatles