Quote Originally Posted by bilbo
I reckon Calzaghe would outpoint him.

Toneys 'prime' at supermiddleweight wasn't that great, losses to Roy Jones and Montell Griffin, a draw with an ancient McCallum.

Toney never had the heart or dedication at middleweight.

Calzaghe UD.

As someone else stated, the losses to Griffin came at LH and the McCallum fight was at MW. Also there is absolutely no shame in losing to a prime Roy at SMW. Roy would have KO'd Calzaghe. Just as I feel Toney probably would have. Toney hit nearly as hard as Lacy at Super Middle and was a master defensive fighter. Calzaghe would probably win some rounds simply by being active at times, but would suffer a late TKO, or 116-112 loss IMO.