How does Winky rank among all-time greats

[TyBuff]

I think Hall of Famers and all time greats is being thrown around alot and way too easy these days
Does Winky deserve to be there? In my opinion NO, he is an excellent fighter and will be remembered but i cant put him the list with the likes of Hagler, Robinson,Tyson, Ali, Foreman so on......

the only present date fighters at the moment would be Bhop, Jones, Oscar and maybe 1 or 2 more
maybe im wrong but let me know

Lot more then that. Tszyu, Barrera, Morales, Castillo, Calzaghe and Arce all deserve to get in in my opinion. I'll gladly make a case for each of them if you wish.

Good call on Tszyu Barrera and Morales, Not sure about Castillo and Calzaghe
dont get me wrong Joe is undefeated but hasnt fought the opposition that Hagler,Hearns,Duran and Leonard had in their day
needs another few more defining fights for me to be honest

I think that Castillo is borderline, it will depend on who he gets to fight @ 140 and how he does against them. I would love to see Calzaghe in a couple more big fights. I think he needs to unify and then move up to 175 to really cement himself. He showed how great he can be against Lacy, but can he do that against everyboyd else? I would love to see it.