I don't think it's possible for a fighter today to compile a resume that matches Robinson's. He beat like 9 hall of famers I think it was, I can't think of anyone who has more then 4 or 5 on their resume today. De La Hoya and potentially Mosley are the only real locks Mayweather has on his. Marquez, Castillo and Gatti are borderline candidates.

I would say he is possibly the best meaning put him in the ring with anyone and he's got a more then favorable chance to win, but his accomplishments will never stack up. Now if you talk the last 30 years then possibly.