Saddo's Pound For Pound Voting (Summer 2010) voting open till May 31st

[Kev]

i don't see how the hell Haye could be top 10 p4p without both Klitschko's being ahead of him, both have better resumes

Because I'm viewing his cruiserweight acomplishents as well. Name me a single other fighter who has been an undisputed world champ unifying the belts in one division, and then moved up and won a world title in the next weight class up, and who WASN'T in the p4p as a result?

What you're basically arguing is that J M Marquez shouldn't be in the p4p because his last fight was at welter and he clearly got dominated. If you think he deserves to be there you must do so on the basis of his acomplishments outside of welterweight, and hence your contradicting yourself.

If it's a p4p ranking, then Hayes acomplishments in the lower weight classes must count too.,

[ElTerribleMorales]

i don't see how the hell Haye could be top 10 p4p without both Klitschko's being ahead of him, both have better resumes

Because I'm viewing his cruiserweight acomplishents as well. Name me a single other fighter who has been an undisputed world champ unifying the belts in one division, and then moved up and won a world title in the next weight class up, and who WASN'T in the p4p as a result?

What you're basically arguing is that J M Marquez shouldn't be in the p4p because his last fight was at welter and he clearly got dominated. If you think he deserves to be there you must do so on the basis of his acomplishments outside of welterweight, and hence your contradicting yourself.

If it's a p4p ranking, then Hayes acomplishments in the lower weight classes must count too.,

Corey Spinks

[Boxer4life]

i would have mayweather as number one, i think he deserves his crown back, he fought a guy everyone wanted to see him fight ...u guys remember right...."why doesnt floyd fight a real welterweight" ...well he did, and he kicked his ass

[OumaFan]

I used to talk about Caballero when I thought he was underrated but he's not a P4P guy IMO.

Montiel should be there over him if you're gonna have a token tiny person.

[Kev]

i don't see how the hell Haye could be top 10 p4p without both Klitschko's being ahead of him, both have better resumes

Because I'm viewing his cruiserweight acomplishents as well. Name me a single other fighter who has been an undisputed world champ unifying the belts in one division, and then moved up and won a world title in the next weight class up, and who WASN'T in the p4p as a result?

What you're basically arguing is that J M Marquez shouldn't be in the p4p because his last fight was at welter and he clearly got dominated. If you think he deserves to be there you must do so on the basis of his acomplishments outside of welterweight, and hence your contradicting yourself.

If it's a p4p ranking, then Hayes acomplishments in the lower weight classes must count too.,

Corey Spinks

No he didn't he was undisputed welterweight champ for a couple fights but was then knocked out by Zab Judah before moving up.

Had he beaten Zab both times and then moved up and won another title you can guarantee he would have been in the p4p top 10.

Actually I can't remember that far back, but I'm pretty sure he was there when he beat Zab first time anway.