Have either of them ever faced someone with even remotely similar styles as the other? I don't think so...this would be so tough to pick but I would pick Winky if I had to.
Good point. i think that calzaghe's style has more advantage cos it is awkward and he throws way more punches. i think joe has faster hands and feet. more power.

WINKY covers up too much. taylor was throwing one-two or- three punch combos.
When you cover up against a fighter like joe, he will throw a flurry of fast accurate and pwerful punches. remember what happened to jeff when he covered up.

I give this fight to joe, either a late stoppage or a points victory.

GO CALZAGHE!!!