To get back on topic, I would favor Montiel, albeit slightly in this fight, he's the more proven commodity at this weight, so i'll put it at around 55-45 for Montiel, however Donaire does have all world skills, no one can deny that, the mystery is will it translate to the 118 dvision, remember although it's only 3 pounds, that is considered to be a big deal for the lower weight divisions.

And Donaire needs this fight more so than Montiel, after his sensational ko of Darchinyan, Donaire has been a massive disappointment for not getting fights done. That falls on the fighter more so than the promoter imo.