Quote Originally Posted by Memphis
The tackle on Lennon was a good one, I screamed penalty just like everyone else, but the replay showed it was good. Carragher went before the whistle, end of.

I thought Crouch was excellent again, came on to do a thankless job, made lots of ball stick and caused one or two problems, cant ask no more than that given the circumstances. We should have gone 4-4-2 when Beckham came off and let Rooney play his game.

He got lennon before he got the ball, if he didnt take lennon he would of never got to the ball. And i hear a whistle for definite when i go back on Sky + whether it was a fans whistle or what i dont know. But it goes and carragher turns round that split second (its slightly obscured by Motson)