Quote Originally Posted by Rantcatrat View Post
Quote Originally Posted by erics44 View Post
Quote Originally Posted by skel1983 View Post
Quote Originally Posted by erics44 View Post
kotelnik quite handily beat maidana

id say he would again

you could posibly say maidana considering khans weeknesses but id say kotelnik is a better

either way guerrero would beat them both if he is still strong at light welter

Obviously never saw the fight.




no, i didnt see it all, from what i saw he deserved it

was it closer than that?

taking away the ortiz fight has maidana showed you anything to suggest he is better than kotelnik?
taking away the ortiz fight doesn't make sense though, given that Ortiz went on to beat Berto up, which made Maidana's win even bigger.
thats true but that is by far and away maidanas best win, he hasnt got to that kind of level before or since