Would you care if Mayweather Jr. never fought again or retired?

[#1FightFan]

I wish he would retire. Who needs fighters like this? Is he a role model? hell 'fuckin' no!
Everyone knows what a piece of shit he is, and what a disgrace to boxing this so called P4P fighter is. He has handpicked opponents for years, and now denies us the biggest fight in boxing today? does he care about legacy? no.

BTW....Castillo beat floyds ass in that first fight. so yes, he did lose a fight.

[FinitoElDinamita]

Fighters have the right to retire whenever they want. It is them who are putting their lives on the line each and everytime they step through those ropes. I wouldnt mind at all if Floyd retires, id actually commend him. Many fighters turn broke when they retire and nobody gives a shit about them. Take Gerald McClellan for example. Only person who's helped him consistantly is Roy Jones while everyone else turned their back on him. Fighters have to look out for their own interest because no one else will ... Shit, Floyd is a multi-millionaire with a resume that most fighters can only dream of having, so if he wants to bow out now, good for him.. People knock on his lack of competition, talking about legacy etc..... let's wake up and live in the real world.. Financial gain and good health is more important than legacy to most people.. and besides, there is nothing wrong with Floyd's legacy.. He's an overachiever..

[marbleheadmaui]

Fighters have the right to retire whenever they want. It is them who are putting their lives on the line each and everytime they step through those ropes. I wouldnt mind at all if Floyd retires, id actually commend him. Many fighters turn broke when they retire and nobody gives a shit about them. Take Gerald McClellan for example. Only person who's helped him consistantly is Roy Jones while everyone else turned their back on him. Fighters have to look out for their own interest because no one else will ... Shit, Floyd is a multi-millionaire with a resume that most fighters can only dream of having, so if he wants to bow out now, good for him.. People knock on his lack of competition, talking about legacy etc..... let's wake up and live in the real world.. Financial gain and good health is more important than legacy to most people.. and besides, there is nothing wrong with Floyd's legacy.. He's an overachiever..

99% of this post is brilliant. The bold is completely wrong. Floyd is an underachiever. He has top ten all-time tools and a top 50 or so resume.