Brian Viloria Back Again

[miron_lang]

so many Hawaiian Punch

Dado Marino, Jesus Salud, Andy Ganigan.


Who is the best Hawaiian Punch?

[marbleheadmaui]

so many Hawaiian Punch

Dado Marino, Jesus Salud, Andy Ganigan.


Who is the best Hawaiian Punch?

I think only Marino was ever a true champion. My God could Andy Ganigan punch. Had there been a gazillion straps in his time he'd have won a couple is my guess. Viloria, when he's on? Is a fine fighter. But very erratic.

I suppose Marino, Viloria, Ganigan, Salud in that order?

But I am really guessing here. What's your take?

[Spicoli]

I've come around on Viloria but his defensive lapses are etched in stone. He is fun TV as they say. I think he falls into shoot out with Segura and gets tko'd. Salud was as solid as they come, bigger, great composure and ring smarts with chin of stone. He'd whip Viloria.

[miron_lang]

[

I think only Marino was ever a true champion. My God could Andy Ganigan punch. Had there been a gazillion straps in his time he'd have won a couple is my guess. Viloria, when he's on? Is a fine fighter. But very erratic.

I suppose Marino, Viloria, Ganigan, Salud in that order?

But I am really guessing here. What's your take?

I have Salud ahead of Ganigan because i have read a source before that he's a WBA 130 champion for 6 yrs. That's along reign. but i double checked on boxrec and its not recorded there. with that i have it exactly like yours.

Marino - A Clear Best of his division in his time
Villoria - 3 Time champion whether we all like it or not
Ganigan - He's a killer puncher, too bad Arguello still got up.
Jesus Salud

[marbleheadmaui]

[

I think only Marino was ever a true champion. My God could Andy Ganigan punch. Had there been a gazillion straps in his time he'd have won a couple is my guess. Viloria, when he's on? Is a fine fighter. But very erratic.

I suppose Marino, Viloria, Ganigan, Salud in that order?

But I am really guessing here. What's your take?

I have Salud ahead of Ganigan because i have read a source before that he's a WBA 130 champion for 6 yrs. That's along reign. but i double checked on boxrec and its not recorded there. with that i have it exactly like yours.

Marino - A Clear Best of his division in his time
Villoria - 3 Time champion whether we all like it or not
Ganigan - He's a killer puncher, too bad Arguello still got up.
Jesus Salud

Sorry but I persist in my never ending battle on the dilution of the word "champion."

If Dado has one, then Brian has zero.