Is Zab Judah an Elite fighter ?

[marbleheadmaui]

To me it's clear that us fans all seem to have different opinions on what elite is.

An elite fighter to me is one of the best in the business.

Pacquiao, Mayweather, Martinez, Marquez, etc to me are "elite" fighters.

Judah's not up there with them, never was.

Obviously other fans think that being world class means your elite, don't think i can agree with it though.

Ricky Hatton was world class who won world title in multiple divisions, etc but came up short against two "elite" fighters. World class operator yes....but elite no.

I guess it's your opinion on it though, keep voting folks.

OK, that helps. But one of the best in the business at a point in time or across time?

[CommunistKevin]

Dude bilbo is slowly growing to genius status in my book. Ha I feel like his posts are almost literally the exact same arguments and opinions that i would state.