who wins a peak mike tyson or lennox lewis

[Master]

He was slipping. In the second fight he had a shocking round midway where he was just taking punches for punches sake and was unlike him. Definitely the unmotivated and ill disciplined version.

I gave reasons for the Tillis performance, and everyone is allowed them, even Lewis such as against Bruno or Tucker. Not a big deal.

Agreed Lewis chin is not weak but he would be conscious of the punches after what has happened to him in the past.

[ICB]

He was slipping. In the second fight he had a shocking round midway where he was just taking punches for punches sake and was unlike him. Definitely the unmotivated and ill disciplined version.

I gave reasons for the Tillis performance, and everyone is allowed them, even Lewis such as against Bruno or Tucker. Not a big deal.

Agreed Lewis chin is not weak but he would be conscious of the punches after what has happened to him in the past.

I gave reasons for the Tillis performance, and everyone is allowed them, even Lewis such as against Bruno or Tucker. Not a big deal.

No you gave an excuse that i've never heard anyone say before not even Tyson and its pretty bad excuse at that.

Bruno is not comparable to Tyson neither is Tucker thats the difference style wise Tillis used movement and his jab and thats what near enough Lewis would do.

[Master]

ICB you take my points way out of context.

For the Tillis fight the reason of the ear infection was given for his poor performance by Rooney I believe. I would believe it as he would have destroyed him if he was on top form.

I never compared Bruno and Tucker to Tyson, take time and read what I write. I said they are examples where Lewis has struggled but it did not mean he was a bad fighter. As Big H said, so he lost some rounds, so he got hit, no big deal it is boxing and it will happen.

[El Gamo]

Yep - The only fault people can pick with Tyson's prime was that so-and-so won 3 or 4 rounds or so-and-so caught with a good shot - woopydoo - it's heavyweight boxing, he couldn't win every minute of every round.

CC,totally agree. That tells you how awesome he was in his prime,if someone survived with him,lasting 12 rounds,it was seen as a success.

He was slipping. In the second fight he had a shocking round midway where he was just taking punches for punches sake and was unlike him. Definitely the unmotivated and ill disciplined version.

I gave reasons for the Tillis performance, and everyone is allowed them, even Lewis such as against Bruno or Tucker. Not a big deal.

Agreed Lewis chin is not weak but he would be conscious of the punches after what has happened to him in the past.

Totally agree and you've made great points throughout,CC bro.

[ICB]

For the Tillis fight the reason of the ear infection was given for his poor performance by Rooney I believe. I would believe it as he would have destroyed him if he was on top form.

I've never heard Tyson use that excuse actually Tyson said that the knockdown saved him in the Tillis fight i've never heard of that excuse by any Tyson fans or Tyson himself so i think its pretty bad excuse if you ask me.


I never compared Bruno and Tucker to Tyson, take time and read what I write. I said they are examples where Lewis has struggled but it did not mean he was a bad fighter. As Big H said, so he lost some rounds, so he got hit, no big deal it is boxing and it will happen.

Thats the thing though Tyson struggled with Tillis and Lewis would use similar tactics to Tillis with the jab and movement and his much longer reach and height advantage Tucker and Bruno are tall fighters and are nothing similar to Tyson so bringing up those fights are pretty pointless i know your not comparing Tucker and Bruno to Tyson but in these match ups you have to look at fights and see what type of style they struggled against Lewis struggled with tall fighters who had good jabs and Tyson also had trouble with taller fighters with good jabs aswell.

[big gaz]

i dont no if this as been said and i may be wrong but did lewis destroy ruddock shortley after tyson beat him?

[ICB]

i dont no if this as been said and i may be wrong but did lewis destroy ruddock shortley after tyson beat him?

It was a year after Ruddock had two fights after the rematch with Tyson he fought Jackson and Page then fought Lewis.

[El Kabong]

.....the same people that say Marciano was too small to beat Tyson are the same people that say Tyson could beat a Prime Lennox Lewis....and they totally forget Lennox was 6'5 250 and Tyson was 5'10 220 ......6 inches, a whole bunch of reach and 30 pounds says Lennox would flatten Tyson no matter when their fight happened.

And Butterbean would beat Muhammad Ali

The Bean was FATTER and he was also never in shape so......yeah Ali was faster and had the reach on pretty much everyone.


Majesty....were talking PRIME Lennox Lewis the big guy who took shots from David Tua with no problem....the guy who took his time and used everything to his advantage.....1-2 if the guy wanted to fight on the outside and the BIG uppercut if the guy wanted to come on the inside.


People here still think a Tyson from 1986-1989 is unbeatable and they are just WRONG WRONG WRONG I could name a ton of fighters that would just whip his ass even when he was on top.

That being said Mike Tyson is a great fighter he was a great champion but you do have to realize his division was weaker than the division right now!!!! No one with power who could box....no one with power and defense....no one with power and a chin....and no one who could box without being scared.

I fully expect the hate to flow freely from all you Tyson fanatics.....it's great you're fans but be reasonable.

[Master]

We can debate how good this current crop of heavyweights are to the ones Tyson fought, but Prime Tyson would beat these heavyweights no problem and no doubt.

[Mr140]

Well one question what is the best win Tyson has a win over a 38 year old Larry Holmes or a Micheal Spinks who is a light heavy wieght champion in truth and the only thing he did is get a gift decisoin against a old Holmes

[Mr140]

Because he was good during his prime but that lose to dougals to me thier no way his prime could of left that fast

[Mr140]

So i do not understand the logic for Tyson being out of prime when he got his first lost

[El Kabong]

We can debate how good this current crop of heavyweights are to the ones Tyson fought, but Prime Tyson would beat these heavyweights no problem and no doubt.

....it's up for debate

[Master]

This is how perverse the arguments can get that now we think a prime Tyson could not the current crop of heavyweights. If Wlad can get knocked down by Samuel Peter he would be knocked out by Tyson. Tyson would smell the vulnerability and fear and crucify Wlad, who is the best heavyweight out there. The rest are not even worthy of debating.

[WelshDevilRob]

Lennox would win - to big and had the jab to control the fight.