
Originally Posted by
El Phenomena
To whomever said Cotto has not fought anyone,you let bias cloud you r judgement and take KT away from Hatton's resume and Cotto has fought by far and away the better opposition.
Corley
ndou
Sosa
Maussa(before Hatton)
Torres(whom he was not expecting to fight)
Bailey
Abdullaev(olympic silver medallist,beat Cotto in amatuers)
mailgnaggi(undefeated slick boxer)
Branco(very fast,only lost1 time,to Gatti and only by points)
lots of ex champs,boxers,punchers,olympians,granted that he needs that big name but that's lots of very good fighters there with excellent records.

Agreed & very well stated.

Originally Posted by
El Phenomena
At 140,Hatton would win because he would maul Cotto and with Cotto being drained,he would fatigue.At 147,I favour Cotto although it would be close.Cotto can fight beautifully on the back foot as seen against Abdullaev and Ndou,his combos and hand speed are beautiful and he would slow Hatton down with body work. Cotto would cut his face if he landed too many times and I believe Miguel to be stronger,so at times,he could puch Htton to his back foot where I don't see him being as effective.
I favor Cotto at 147 over Hatton...Cotto needs to stay at 147 period. He's looked his worst when he was fighting to make 140. The problem with Cotto vs Hatton is that Cotto would fight Hatton's fight IWO.
I thought that Cotto was most effective when he was boxing. If you roll back to the Sosa fight...that's when he was the best...after that...he started listening to HBO & believeing the hype.
He's a much better boxer than he is a brawler IWO. He is not the new Tito...he needs to give that up. He's much better than Tito, IWHO, as I don't really rate or dig Tito...who often gave off a deer in headlights aura once the power shots failed him.

Originally Posted by
El Phenomena
PBF is a tough fight for anyone but Miguel,in a year or2,would be tough for him too,although I'd favour a Floyd win.
Being a fan of both...but a bigger fan of Floyd's abilities...I can honestly say that this would be the one fight that Cotto should never take.

Originally Posted by
El Phenomena
Miguel knocks Zab out or stops him on body shot,end of.
Agreed. Zab down the stretch falls apart & Cotto eats him alive.

Originally Posted by
El Phenomena
I just think if Miguel went to war with Tony,he would lose and if he boxed,Margarito is so effective at working the body and cutting the ring off that he would still lose although I could be wrong.
I don't really rate Margarito. I think Cotto would pretty much wear him down after a long battle. If Cotto would use his defense he could win the fight.

Originally Posted by
El Phenomena
Cotto would beat Collazo for me,even though I change my mind about Collazo alot,remember,before the HATTON fight,he took a fight with guy with a 1-1 record and I think he is good but maybe not as good as everyone thinks,more indicative of Hatton maybe?
Disagree totally. If Collazo were to box Cotto...Cotto would lose. I was really impressed with Collazo & his abilities & moreover...his ability to survive. I truly believe that he gives Cotto hell all night on abilities alone.

Originally Posted by
El Phenomena
Cotto could beat Castillo,as long as he boxed,if he stands toe to toe,he is getting knocked the F out!!
Agreed. I don't really rate Castillo though...but it's more that I don't like his ass, to be honest. Castillo kind of frightens me for Cotto. Here again, as with Margarito, if Cotto fought smart he could win down the stretch. Cotto would use his defense & the ring to beat Castillo. Castillo's just such a heavy hitter that loves to trade. I think that it's also a bad fight for Cotto.
Bookmarks