gerald mcclellan vs tommy hearns who wins

[JT Rock]

if mcclelan couldnt beat benn he couldnt beat hearns.

totally different fighters benn ducked under gerald punches plus benn must have preyed to god because he took terrible beating he fought his heart out fight was so damaging benn was finished after that fight remember hearns was koed by iran barkley so i think gerald would get that chin aswell

It's much simpler then that imo.

Trinidad's best weight was 147 so was Hearns I believe. And Trinidad could not and would not beat Hearns at 147 or 154.

Gerald's best weight is at 160. Whereas it wasn't Hearns' best one he'd be at a disadvantage from the start. And its very possible given his chin that Gerald would have detinated him eventually and besides that Gerald had an iron chin.

Trinidad didn't, even at 147.

This is why people would say that Gerald could beat Hearns, but Trinidad couldn't.

Agreed and Congrats on reaching 1000 posts

[dennis]

i'm a fan of benn as well but this is just geting stupid

[ICB]

if mcclelan couldnt beat benn he couldnt beat hearns.

That Philosophy and Formula never means anything...Styles make fights...I think Nigel Benn at 160 could probably Take Hearns as well...Nigel was another freak of nature

gerald would catch tommy sooner or later then bye bye hearns dont get me wrong hearns is great fighter but he didnt quite have the chin gerald had better chin and gerald could bang very hard one of best infact and i think gerald wouldnt catch him and ko for gerald

[dennis]

like i said. similar to the herans and duran fight. hearns wins KO.

[ICB]

like i said. similar to the herans and duran fight. hearns wins KO.

nah gerald is tall and has got great chin i think it would be similar to barkley vs hearns 1

[Majesty]

like i said. similar to the herans and duran fight. hearns wins KO.

That would be how Trinidad vs. Hearns would turn out.

[dennis]

mcllelan is no duran

[ICB]

mcllelan is no duran

duran was alot shorter and couldnt get inside against hearns

[Majesty]

The Duran Hearns ko is more similar to what would happen to Trinidad.

[gyrokai]

Gerald's chin was sturdy, but once it was tested, he lost. Right?

This fight isn't fair anyways, Gerald is too big anyhow.
P4P, Gerald never had the chance to challenge Tommy's Punching Power Status,
because his career was cut short. But before it, his power was unbelievable.
He was just so aggresive.

[JT Rock]

I just couldnt see Tommy losing to gerald mcllelan. no disrespect to him becasue like i said they are both terrific fighters but i think hearns would have landed quick and powerful blows and KO gerald. a bit like what he done to the great roberto duran.

Ok heres the deal My man..... Tommy Hearns is 6'1 and used his jab to keep Roberto Duran who was only 5'7 at the end of his right hand and he was the bigger stronger man....Gerald McClellan is 6'2 and is naturally bigger and more physical than Tommy Hearns...So thats why you cant use another fight as an example to predetermine another one....Styles make fights

[Majesty]

Gerald's chin was sturdy, but once it was tested, he lost.  Right?

This fight isn't fair anyways, Gerald is too big anyhow.  
P4P, Gerald never had the chance to challenge Tommy's Punching Power Status,
because his career was cut short.  But before it, his power was unbelievable.  
He was just so aggresive.

No, Julian Jackson tested it

[ICB]

I just couldnt see Tommy losing to gerald mcllelan. no disrespect to him becasue like i said they are both terrific fighters but i think hearns would have landed quick and powerful blows and KO gerald. a bit like what he done to the great roberto duran.

Ok heres the deal My man..... Tommy Hearns is 6'1 and used his jab to keep Roberto Duran who was only 5'7 at the end of his right hand and he was the bigger stronger man....Gerald McClellan is 6'2 and is naturally bigger and more physical than Tommy Hearns...So thats why you cant use another fight as an example to predetermine another one....Styles make fights

it would be similar to barkley vs hearns 1 jt barkley was about 6 foot 1 or 6 foot wasnt he ??

[Bookkeeper]

if mcclelan couldnt beat benn he couldnt beat hearns.

That Philosophy and Formula never means anything...Styles make fights...I think Nigel Benn at 160 could probably Take Hearns as well...Nigel was another freak of nature

You should be focused on selling Gap, Carcare, and making two points on the backend

[dennis]

styles do make fights. tommy hearns would be my choice and gerald yours. fair enough. At the end of the day it would be a great fight and thats what its all about.


Tommys the winner though. HAHAHA