Marvin Hagler's chin. How would it hold up to Julian Jackson or Nigel Benn.

[JT Rock]

Hagler-Wright would be the toughest fight for him I think....Winky just has such a tight defense.....it's hard to believe he got rocked so many times by Julio Cesar Vasquez




Don't want to be an a** but it's the OCCIPITAL LOBE and BRAIN STEM that are affected by rabbit punches

Thank you Dr Lyle, you could of PM'd me and let me know that instead of calling me out in front of the masses ...Then again I am a exibitionist... That head butt Gerald took to his right Orbital has been well documented and for whatever reason added to the already fast declining state of trauma he was suffering from countless fouls and Brutal exchanges

[Violent Demise]

.....not even Tommy Hearns? Gerald McClellan? or even Roy Jones Jr?

No.

[LegendBoxing65]

I tend to agree. Julian punched in someways harder than Mugabi. He seemed to have the punching ability to knock out whoever he hit clean. Remember Buster Drayton? Herol Graham? Terry Norris? Now those guys are not Marvelous Marvin, but it would be interesting to see Julian's punch uncorked on Marvin's chin. It would have been hard to see Marvin Hagler go down like a pole and Julian doing that hand gesture as he was falling, but who knows. Julian was a guy who would hit guys and they wouldn't seem to react. Like he was sort of hitting soft soft soft, and then he would save his knockout punch for the end.

[JT Rock]

.....not even Tommy Hearns? Gerald McClellan? or even Roy Jones Jr?

No.

I dont know about that Bro ....Ask Julian How hard Gerald hit Gerald took Julians power but Julian Couldnt even deter Gerald...

Mcclellan Knocked Jackson the Fuk out twice without even Blinking...

[EverlastReyes]

Julian was all but washed up by the time he fought Gerald. By the way, Congratulations for Julian being inducted into the Hall of Fame in Los Angeles a month ago. Gerald was a hard puncher ,but Julian was a guy who literally poleaxed a guy. Is that the right word? What exactly is poleaxed? I have heard that word and it seems to describe Julian's punching.

[bigragu]

Marvin Hagler's chin held up to the punches of Tommy Hearns and John Mugabi. How would it hold up to a guy like Julian Jackson or Nigel Benn?

his chin was unbreakable!!! I think Hagler had one of the best chins in boxing!!!

[Majesty]

.....not even Tommy Hearns? Gerald McClellan? or even Roy Jones Jr?

No.

I dont know about that Bro ....Ask Julian How hard Gerald hit Gerald took Julians power but Julian Couldnt even deter Gerald...

Mcclellan Knocked Jackson the Fuk out twice without even Blinking...

Jackson didn't have much of a chin, surely none like Haglers. Its a repeat of the Mugabi fight?

[JT Rock]

Julian was all but washed up by the time he fought Gerald. By the way, Congratulations for Julian being inducted into the Hall of Fame in Los Angeles a month ago. Gerald was a hard puncher ,but Julian was a guy who literally poleaxed a guy. Is that the right word? What exactly is poleaxed? I have heard that word and it seems to describe Julian's punching.

Yes congrats to him he was a fine warrior...Power is the last thing to go...Again if anything I would feel comfortable saying they punched almost the same both could end fight at any moment whether it was the 1st minute of roudn 1 or the last minute of round 12.. but I wouldnt give Julian the nod Over Gerald...McClellan was a freak of nature plain and simple

[bigragu]

Julian was all but washed up by the time he fought Gerald. By the way, Congratulations for Julian being inducted into the Hall of Fame in Los Angeles a month ago. Gerald was a hard puncher ,but Julian was a guy who literally poleaxed a guy. Is that the right word? What exactly is poleaxed? I have heard that word and it seems to describe Julian's punching.

Yes congrats to him he was a fine warrior...Power is the last thing to go...Again if anything I would feel comfortable saying they punched almost the same both could end fight at any moment whether it was the 1st minute of roudn 1 or the last minute of round 12.. but I wouldnt give Julian the nod Over Gerald...McClellan was a freak of nature plain and simple

G-MAN was a Badddddd man!!!! I think Jackson was a really good but not great fighter.....G-MAN was great..cut down in his prime.....and his chin was better than Jackson's.....

[Violent Demise]

Julian was all but washed up by the time he fought Gerald. By the way, Congratulations for Julian being inducted into the Hall of Fame in Los Angeles a month ago. Gerald was a hard puncher ,but Julian was a guy who literally poleaxed a guy. Is that the right word? What exactly is poleaxed? I have heard that word and it seems to describe Julian's punching.

Very well said. I've always liked G-man but nobody hit harder at 160 than Jackson

[LegendBoxing65]

Julian was a scary puncher. And there are not that many of those. Mugabi was one and so was Julian. Herol Graham was winning the fight and the bomb just took him out cold. And it was not a left or a right for Julian. Either punch would knock a guy out.

[X]

Hagler had one of the best chins of all time in any weight division.

I don't think he was ever truly stunned in his career and I can't see Jackson or Benn getting past his underrated defense, never mind stopping or dropping him.

I also think that there's a great deal of revisionism going on about Gerald McClellan. It is sad what happened to the guy, but let's not lose sight of the fact that he did not fight anybody remotely good until Benn (Jackson was never anything more than a big right), it is not that hard to rack up impressive KOs against tomato cans. Yes, he was a good fighter ...... but great - I don't think so.

He was also an unpleasant guy full of bravado, continually calling people out and glorifying in his reputation as a violent, dog-fighing thug who would go to war with anyone who looked at him wrongly.

He picked the wrong guy in Benn, who showed him what a 'tear-up' is really about.

I am definitely not saying he deserved what he got, and I was at that fight. But we need not create some kind of martyred saviour and mourn the loss of one of the greatest fighters of all time ..... because Gerald was neither (IMO).

[Poom]

DId anyone ever knock down Hagler?

[WWatt]

Who knows?

Hagler never fought anybody who could hit as hard as Benn, or Jackson for that matter. He hasn't fought a KO artist like Jackson, either, who even surpasses Hearns in that department.

Benn's the hardest-hitting middleweight ever, as well as the most ferocious fighter ever, and had more snap in his punches than the Sibson's and Mugabi's and threw shots from more angles.. Hagler himself said Benn would be his toughest fight if he hadn't retired!


Benn and Hagler would of been fun while it lasted, but Benn's shaky chin would of let him down.

[WWatt]

DId anyone ever knock down Hagler?

Yeah, Roldan, but I think it was more of a flash knockdown if I remember.