If calzaghe was to fight............

[Hulk]

If he beats Kessler - people say Kessler was a rookie and hadn't fought anybody, was overhyped

If he beats Taylor people say he was fighting a much smaller guy and Taylor was overrated anyway

If he beats Hopkins People say Hopkins was old and shot

If he beats Froch, same argument as Kessler

If he beats Superman, Spiderman, The bionic Man, Maruis Pujenowski, Nicolai Valuev and Goliath people say he ducked Hulk Hogan and will still not give him credit FACT

Damn straight. He's been duckin the Hulkster for years now.

[althetruthhindley]

kessler and blew him apart like he did lacy, would u all say whos kessler fought though to make him a great or would u respect him

same as taylor, would u say great win or well he's fighting a middleweight

personally he could retire tomo, hes got nothin left to prove to me.

but it seems to some like nothings good enough, always someone he hasnt fought, but hes got 2 more fights left in him IMO and after that boxings lost a great in calzaghe

In my opinion Joe Calzaghe is a top fighter but fighting in a weak division againest second rate fighters most of your career does not make a boxing great , SRR was great Joe Calzaghe retires now you consider him great ? I DONT THINK SO SOME HOW !!!!!!!!!!!!

[TheBESTP4P]

kessler and blew him apart like he did lacy, would u all say whos kessler fought though to make him a great or would u respect him

same as taylor, would u say great win or well he's fighting a middleweight

personally he could retire tomo, hes got nothin left to prove to me.

but it seems to some like nothings good enough, always someone he hasnt fought, but hes got 2 more fights left in him IMO and after that boxings lost a great in calzaghe

i would actually give him mad props if he did fight kessler and defeated him convincingly. i actually like to see JC unify then go down or make someone come up to be honest.

[Tysonbruno]

Calzaghe is a shower of shite if he ever fights Kessler or Taylor he gets beat infact ive said before that Froch would'nt beat him but i think he would now actually thats if Kessler or Taylor would come over to fight him after the state of the stoppage the other night i bet they will be thinking twice

[beds]

calzaghe wont go down, he struggles to stay in the super middle but i dont think he'll leave the division, were he belongs

kessler and blew him apart like he did lacy, would u all say whos kessler fought though to make him a great or would u respect him

same as taylor, would u say great win or well he's fighting a middleweight

personally he could retire tomo, hes got nothin left to prove to me.

but it seems to some like nothings good enough, always someone he hasnt fought, but hes got 2 more fights left in him IMO and after that boxings lost a great in calzaghe

In my opinion Joe Calzaghe is a top fighter but fighting in a weak division againest second rate fighters most of your career does not make a boxing great , SRR was great Joe Calzaghe retires now you consider him great ? I DONT THINK SO SOME HOW !!!!!!!!!!!!

if holding a belt for 9 years, unifying ur division and staying unbeaten with 20 defenses doesnt make u a great i dunno wat will

[ICB]

calzaghe wont go down, he struggles to stay in the super middle but i dont think he'll leave the division, were he belongs

kessler and blew him apart like he did lacy, would u all say whos kessler fought though to make him a great or would u respect him

same as taylor, would u say great win or well he's fighting a middleweight

personally he could retire tomo, hes got nothin left to prove to me.

but it seems to some like nothings good enough, always someone he hasnt fought, but hes got 2 more fights left in him IMO and after that boxings lost a great in calzaghe

In my opinion Joe Calzaghe is a top fighter but fighting in a weak division againest second rate fighters most of your career does not make a boxing great , SRR was great Joe Calzaghe retires now you consider him great ? I DONT THINK SO SOME HOW !!!!!!!!!!!!

if holding a belt for 9 years, unifying ur division and staying unbeaten with 20 defenses doesnt make u a great i dunno wat will

But who has he beaten exactly beds ?? just look at list of opponents he really has fought and your find there is not one great opponent on the list a champion could make 50 defenses against crap and mediocre opponents but does that him great ?? no it doesn't Calzaghe could of fought much better opponents but hasn't and i wonder why he hasn't got one great name on his list of defenses.