BEST SUPERMIDDLE?

[Taeth]

JR!

Jerry Rice?

[Taeth]

nvm I wasn't expecting you to use a cheap tactic like putting one name into three posts to up your post number j/k

[CutMeMick]

Quality, not quantity.

Remember that.

[THE THIRD MAN]

[quote=ICE COLD BOXING ]
Roy Jones Jr the guy was so talented that he never even tried what a talent he was from Roy Jones himself = they say i fight nobody its not that i make them look like nobody
[/quoteAgreed!

[spanky-banky]

Since I rate RJJ at Light Heavy. as IMO he accomplished more there.
I voted Collins.

Now if your talking about who was the best as far as skills then the slight advantage goes to RJJ followed by Toney.

People can be the best of more than one divison I believe Roy was the best SMW, and LHW ever.

roy jones was the best super middle ever imo but at light heavy , spinks and holy would beat him

[Tysonbruno]

Holyfield was cruiserweight

[TheBESTP4P]

no seriously could u guys imagine seriously if roy never left the SMW division GOD DAMN he would of MASSACRED that division it would of been like a genocide man!

[CutMeMick]

no seriously could u guys imagine seriously if roy never left the SMW division GOD DAMN he would of MASSACRED that division it would of been like a genocide man!

Well who knows really cause the question is "Would RJJ, Eubank, Benn & Collins all have met"?

[TheBESTP4P]

no seriously could u guys imagine seriously if roy never left the SMW division GOD DAMN he would of MASSACRED that division it would of been like a genocide man!

Well who knows really cause the question is "Would RJJ, Eubank, Benn & Collins all have met"?

valid point but RJJ has all the LEGIT reasoning to never leave the US after what KOREA did to him on the realz yo i dont blame him at all.

[Tysonbruno]

Steve Collins and Benn called Jones out loads but he never bit

[babyboNe]

this is easy, best supermiddle weight is only ROY JONES JR.

joe. C and his b1tch a$$ 20th defense that is a damn shame, he fought a reality show guy for god sake. who does that? what an embarrASSment,a damn shame in boxing history guys like this makes 20th defense.

i'm getting sick of this undefeated protected punk fighters.

ROY JONES JR whoops him big time.

[Larryboy]

I'll go for Nigel Benn. He fought at the weight for a long time, racked up 9 defences, had some exciting fights, and turned back the challenge of a really dangerous fighter who was heavily tipped to beat him (Mclellan). Roy Jones was very talented but really didn't do that much at super middleweight.

[the big K]

this is easy, best supermiddle weight is only ROY JONES JR.

joe. C and his b1tch a$$ 20th defense that is a damn shame, he fought a reality show guy for god sake. who does that? what an embarrASSment,a damn shame in boxing history guys like this makes 20th defense.

i'm getting sick of this undefeated protected punk fighters.

ROY JONES JR whoops him big time.

I'm with you

[the phenom]

jones

[Gandalf]

no seriously could u guys imagine seriously if roy never left the SMW division GOD DAMN he would of MASSACRED that division it would of been like a genocide man!

Well who knows really cause the question is "Would RJJ, Eubank, Benn & Collins all have met"?

valid point but RJJ has all the LEGIT reasoning to never leave the US after what KOREA did to him on the realz yo i dont blame him at all.

That is not a valid reason for any fighter that believes in himself not to go abroad and fight 12 hard rounds!


And besides beating James Toney who did Jones Jr beat at SMW exactly anyways? Am I missing something here? Are we talking about quality of opponents? Skill differentials or what? This thread is lost on me really!