Will Kelly Pavlik Be in Top 10 P4P If He Beats Jermain Taylor Again ??

[southakron314]

Taylor beats number four twice in Hopkins. Pavlik beats Taylor by knock out? Pavlik not in the top ten?

[TitoFan]

I'm a huge fan of Pavlik's and will be rooting for him again vs. Taylor. But I think top 10 talk is premature. Let's use the same measuring stick for him that we use for all the others. You gotta have a few more big names on your resume besides Taylor and Miranda before you start bumping other, more deserving fighters for top 10 p4p. Just MHO, of course.

[El Gamo]

I think in my last list,I had Kelly at 10 anyway,but some thought that was too high.In hindsight,I can agree with them.I don't think a win would move him any higher although,strangley,it does show us what Kelly would be like at 168,because JT is a 168 pounder after this fight,win lose or draw I think.

Calderon has to be on all P4P lists. He is THE definition of a P4P fighter,dominating 1 weight class,and moving up and fighting the best of the next weight class in his first fight. NOT skimming divisions or scraping the barrell with opponents,hand picking them. Even esquer,is a tough opponent.

All top 5 have these names in some order: Floyd,Manny,JMM,JC and B Hop. After that,for the next 5,these are the names which imo should be mentioned or are contenders for the next place:

Cotto
Calderon
Pavlik
Rafa
Vazquez(the winner of their fight will prob be number 5)
J Diaz(he has the weakest argument thus far because of a lack of big wins,lots of decent to good ones)
Winky Wright

[NorthSideX4]

Tayor is no pushover & INO has learned alot from the first fight! I wouldn't go and count my chickens before they hatch!